First, the conclusion:The correct sequence for anchor selection isFirst assess the base material, then the load, and finally the environmental and installation conditions. The reason is straightforward — the base material determines 'which anchors are physically not allowed,' while the load only determines 'which size to choose among those allowed.' Once the sequence is reversed, rework such as 'beautiful pull-out calculations, but cracked concrete base material with expansion anchors selected' occurs. This article sets out a practical three-step assessment sequence, the correspondence between base materials and products, and the five most common misjudgments on site.
Scope of application:This article applies to the preliminary selection of post-installed anchors in concrete and masonry base materials, covering four categories: undercut anchors, self-undercutting anchors, chemical anchors, and expansion anchors. Panel-side selection of curtain wall back bolts and the pre-embedding selection logic of cast-in channels follow different principles and are outside the scope of this article; see the selection guides of the corresponding Daring product lines.
In actual projects, the most common error in anchor selection is not 'miscalculation' but 'wrong sequence.' Many engineers instinctively start by calculating the load: how many kilonewtons a single anchor carries, what safety factor to use, and then look up a load capacity table to pick a sufficiently large model. This logic is not wrong in itself, but it misses a prerequisite —whether the anchor you have chosen can actually be used in that base material. This article breaks selection into three sequential assessment steps, each answering one question, to avoid precise calculations within the wrong candidate set.
I. Why the Substrate Must Come First and the Load Second
1.1 The Substrate Is a Hard Constraint, the Load a Soft Constraint
The two are fundamentally different. Load is a constraint of quantity — once calculated, you select the corresponding specification from the load capacity table; models can be increased all the way from M8 to M16 and M20, and there is always a way to meet the requirement. The substrate, however, is a constraint of category — it directly determines whether an entire class of anchors is excluded by the codes, and this cannot be circumvented simply by increasing the size.
The most typical case is the expansion anchor. It obtains its anchoring force by a cone compressing the expansion sleeve, generating radial expansion stress on the hole wall. This mechanism works well in uncracked concrete, but fails outright in three situations: first, cracked concrete, the crack will continue to open under expansion stress, and anchoring force decays rapidly as the crack widens; second,Small edge distances and small spacings, there is not enough concrete confinement for the radial stress, easily splitting the base material; third,Masonry, hollow brick, aerated concrete, the base material itself has very low tensile strength, and the expansion stress will split the block directly. In these three cases, changing the expansion anchor from M10 to M16 will only make things worse rather than better.
Conversely, undercut anchors bear load through a mechanical lock at the hole bottom,and generate no radial expansion stress, so they remain usable in 'no-go zones for expansion anchors' such as cracked concrete, small edge distances, and thin-walled members. In other words, assessing the base material first narrows the candidate set from 'dozens of models' to 'one or two product categories' in one step, making the subsequent load calculation meaningful.
1.2 The cost of reversing the sequence: rework, re-inspection, and even design changes
A reversed sequence usually does not show up at the drawing stage but on site: holes have been drilled, anchors installed, and pull-out tests completed before it is discovered that a certain area is cracked concrete or has insufficient edge distance, and the load capacity falls short of the design requirement. The cost of dealing with this at that point is far higher than re-selecting — either expand inspection and double sampling, relocate and re-drill the entire area, or add connection steel plates for strengthening, with a design change as the worst case.
A more insidious cost is 'barely compliant.' In some projects, expansion anchors are installed in cracked concrete and the pull-out test passes — because the crack did not open during the test. However, the code requirement for cracked concrete is that load capacity be maintained undercyclic crack opening at a crack width of 0.3mm, and passing a static pull-out test does not equal long-term safety. Such hidden defects are not visible in as-built documentation but will appear years later as loosened panels or displacement of connections.
II. The three-step assessment sequence: one question answered at each step
2.1 Step 1: Base material assessment — what can be used
Four things must be confirmed at this step; missing any one may lead to a wrong selection:
Base material type: uncracked concrete, cracked concrete (or tension zones likely to crack), or masonry, hollow brick, or aerated concrete blocks.
Strength grade: Concrete strength directly affects anchoring load capacity; at the same size, C20 and C40 can differ by a full grade in load capacity.
Edge distance and spacing: The distance from the anchor center to the member edge, and the spacing between anchors in a group. Insufficient edge distance is a common cause of failure in expansion anchors.
Base material thickness: For thin panels and thin-walled members, consider whether drilling will break through and whether through-anchoring is permitted on the back side.
Applying these four conditions to the table below generally narrows the choice to one or two product categories, and the remaining categories can be ruled out directly.
| Base material condition | Preferred product | To be excluded | Basis for judgment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Uncracked concrete with ample edge distance | Expansion anchors, undercut anchors, and chemical anchors are all acceptable | No hard exclusions | Select based on load and cost effectiveness |
| Cracked concrete | Undercut anchors, self-undercutting anchors, special chemical anchors | Ordinary expansion anchors, ordinary chemical anchors | A load capacity report under cyclic crack opening at a crack width of 0.3mm must be provided |
| Small edge distance / small spacing | Undercut anchors, self-undercutting anchors | Expansion anchors | The mechanical lock generates no radial expansion stress |
| Fired hollow brick / masonry | Special masonry anchors, through-wall threaded rods | All expansion anchors and mechanical undercut anchors | Insufficient tensile strength of the base material; the hole wall cannot provide reaction force for the lock |
| Thin panels / thin-walled members | Through-anchoring with backing steel plates, chemical anchors with mesh sleeves | Ordinary undercut anchors | Embedment depth insufficient to form a complete concrete cone |
2.2 Step 2: Load assessment — how large is needed
Only after the candidate set is determined do we move to the load calculation step. Three variables must be clarified at this step:Load direction(tension, shear, or combined loading),Load nature(static, dynamic, seismic, or fatigue),single anchor or anchor group. Even for the same M12 size, the design values for tension and shear are not of the same order of magnitude, and dynamic loading requires additional consideration of stress amplitude and number of cycles.
The nature of the load is easily overlooked here. Curtain walls subjected to wind vibration, equipment foundations subjected to vibration, and rail transit subjected to long-term dynamic loads are all fatigue conditions, requiring anchors with corresponding fatigue resistance — the industry-standard verification method is 2 million loading cycles. For seismic conditions, check whether the anchor has passed seismic performance class assessment and how it performs under rare-earthquake displacement. Neither can be substituted by simply 'choosing a larger size.'
In addition, safety factors must match the load combination. The partial factors differ for static, seismic, and fatigue conditions, and applying the same factor across the board is a common error. At the design stage, the design values in code provisions and product certification reports should govern, rather than dividing the 'ultimate pull-out force' in a product catalog by an empirical factor.
2.3 Step 3: Environmental and installation assessment — how to install and whether installation is possible
The final step determines the material, corrosion protection configuration, and construction route, mainly covering four items:
Temperature: Chemical anchors rely on adhesive curing; low temperatures significantly extend curing time, and ordinary adhesives hardly react properly below 0℃; mechanical anchors are unaffected by temperature, locking immediately on installation with no curing wait.
Humidity and standing water: When standing water is present in the hole, conventional chemical anchor injection can cause adhesive segregation and bond failure, requiring a special anti-washout underwater adhesive or a switch to mechanical anchors.
Corrosive environment: Coastal high salt spray, swimming pool high chlorine, chemical plant areas, and wet-dry cycling environments impose different requirements on materials and coatings. Hot-dip galvanized carbon steel suits general outdoor environments; highly corrosive environments should be upgraded to 304/316 stainless steel or a supplemented coating system.
Schedule and site working conditions: Whether hot work is permitted, whether same-day load bearing is required, and whether winter construction is needed all feed back into the choices made in the first two steps.
At this point, the selection has essentially converged on a defined combination of 'product + size + material + surface treatment,' and the process can move to technical submittal and quotation.
III. Comparison of key differences among four anchor types
The preceding assessment logic is condensed into a table for quick comparison during drawing reviews or site briefings.
| Comparison item | Expansion anchor | Undercut anchor | Self-undercutting anchor | Chemical anchor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Load-bearing mechanism | Cone compression with radial expansion stress | Mechanical lock at the hole bottom | Integrated cutting and undercutting lock at the hole bottom | Adhesive bonding plus mechanical engagement of the threaded rod |
| Cracked concrete | Not applicable | Applicable (with certification report) | Applicable (with a certification report) | requires specially certified products |
| Small edge distance | prone to edge spalling, restricted | Usable | Usable | Usable, depends on substrate integrity |
| Temperature influence | None | None, ready for immediate use | None, ready for immediate use | Significant, requires waiting for curing |
| Installation procedure | Drilling → hole cleaning → installation | Drilling → secondary reaming → hole cleaning → installation | Drilling → hole cleaning → hammer installation (cutting and reaming synchronized) | Drilling → hole cleaning → adhesive injection → insertion → curing |
| Removability | Removable and reusable | Removable (threaded rod replaceable) | Removable (threaded rod replaceable) | Essentially non-removable |
| Typical scenarios | Light loads, uncracked substrate, temporary fixing | Curtain walls, seismic zones, small edge distances, heavy loads | Large sizes, tight schedules, equipment foundations | Dense anchoring points, areas with dense reinforcement, where avoidance is needed |
IV. The Five Most Common Misjudgments on Site
4.1 Misjudgment 1: Calculating the Load First, Then Looking for a Product
This is the most widespread one. After calculating the load, the designer picks a model from the load capacity table and takes whichever one comes up, without ever checking the substrate conditions. The result is often that the selected product is simply not suitable for cracked concrete or small edge-distance locations, and choosing a higher-capacity version of the same product only makes the problem worse.
4.2 Misjudgment 2: Using Expansion Anchors for Every Scenario
Expansion anchors are cheap, readily available and familiar to workers, so they are often treated as the default choice. But they are explicitly unsuitable in three scenarios — cracked concrete, small edge distances and masonry — not because the result is 'slightly worse' but because the mechanical mechanism does not hold.
4.3 Misjudgment 3: Solving Insufficient Edge Distance by 'Increasing the Size'
Insufficient edge distance means there is not enough concrete confining volume; increasing the size simply increases the expansion stress, so failure occurs even earlier — typically as spalling at the hole mouth and splitting of the substrate along the edge. The correct approach is to switch to a mechanical-keying anchor with no expansion stress, or to transfer the load by adding a connecting steel plate or providing backing.
4.4 Misjudgment 4: Treating Chemical Anchors as a Universal Solution
Chemical anchors do have advantages in areas with dense reinforcement, densely spaced anchoring points and irregular substrates, but they are the most sensitive to installation conditions: standing water in the hole, dust not removed, too-low temperature or insufficient curing time — any one of these problems will significantly weaken the anchoring force. In low-temperature seasons and damp environments, where the process conditions cannot be guaranteed, mechanical anchors are often the more reliable choice.
4.5 Misjudgment 5: Comparing Only Pull-Out Force Figures, Not Failure Modes and Certifications
Pull-out force figures in different manufacturers' catalogues are often not directly comparable — some are ultimate values and some are design values; some are measured on C20 substrate and some on C40. Comparing the numbers side by side is meaningless. What should really be compared are three things:whether the certification covers cracked concrete and seismic applications, whether the failure mode is controllable (i.e. whether steel failure rather than concrete cone failure can be achieved), and whether the reports are traceable.. This is also why ETA certification under the ETAG 001 system, seismic performance class assessment, and test reports with traceable numbers are more valuable references than a single number in a catalog.
V. Daring's Mechanical Anchor Product Support
Corresponding to the three-step assessment above, Daring's mechanical anchor range covers undercut anchors, self-undercutting anchors, drop-in expansion anchors, Anka anchors, and heavy-duty mechanical anchors. Materials include grade 5.8/8.8 carbon steel and 304/316 stainless steel, surface treatments include electroplated zinc and hot-dip galvanizing (coating thickness up to 50μm or more), and sizes range from M6 to M20. Key product parameters are as follows:
| Item | Parameter |
|---|---|
| Product category | Undercut anchors, self-undercutting anchors, drop-in expansion anchors, Anka anchors, heavy-duty mechanical anchors |
| Material | Grade 5.8 carbon steel, grade 8.8 carbon steel, 304 stainless steel, 316 stainless steel |
| Surface treatment | Electroplated zinc, hot-dip galvanizing (≥50μm) |
| Applicable base material | Cracked/uncracked concrete C20–C60 |
| Certification and testing | EU ETA certification, Class S anchor certification, seismic test under a rare earthquake of intensity 9, 2 million cycle fatigue test, salt spray test |
| Design service life | Up to 50 years when installed in accordance with codes (JGJ 145-2013 stipulates that the design service life of post-installed anchoring should not be less than 30 years) |
Materials provided during the selection stage include: product selection calculation sheets, complete test reports and quality certificates, on-site inspection tools such as hole gauges and hole probes, and BIM family files for direct use by design institutes.
VI. Frequently Asked Questions
| Q1 | What exactly should be done first in anchor selection? First determine the base material: confirm whether it is cracked or uncracked concrete, its strength grade, edge distances and spacings, and base material thickness. This step determines which anchors are physically unusable; it is a constraint at the 'category' level and cannot be bypassed by simply increasing the size. |
| Q2 | Which anchor should be selected for cracked concrete? Undercut anchors or self-undercutting anchors are preferred; they bear load through a mechanical lock at the bottom of the hole and generate no radial expansion stress. Special chemical anchors certified for cracked concrete may also be used. Ordinary expansion anchors and ordinary chemical anchors are not suitable. The criterion is whether the product can provide a load capacity report under cyclic crack opening at a crack width of 0.3mm. |
| Q3 | If the edge distance is only 5cm, can expansion anchors still be used? Not recommended. When the edge distance is insufficient, the expansion stress lacks sufficient concrete confinement, easily causing edge spalling or splitting along the edge; increasing the size only makes it worse. Use mechanical-lock anchors that generate no expansion stress instead, or transfer the load to a more favorable location by adding connection steel plates or backing. |
| Q4 | For construction in winter at -5℃, should chemical anchors or mechanical anchors be selected? Both options are feasible, but under different conditions: chemical anchors require a low-temperature anchoring adhesive and a longer curing wait time; mechanical anchors are unaffected by temperature, lock immediately upon installation with no curing required, giving better schedule control. If curing conditions for the adhesive cannot be guaranteed on site, prefer mechanical anchors. |
| Q5 | Is a higher pull-out force in a catalog always better? They cannot be compared that way. Catalog figures often use inconsistent bases — ultimate values versus design values, and results measured in C20 versus C40 base materials can differ substantially. Compare three things: whether the certification covers cracked concrete and seismic conditions, whether the failure mode is controllable, and whether the test report has a traceable number. |
| Q6 | What technical documents can be requested from Daring during the selection stage? You can request product selection calculation sheets, complete certification and test reports, quality certificates, BIM family files, and a list of supporting tools such as hole gauges, hole probes, and special hammer-in sleeves. For complex projects, the technical team can participate in drawing reviews to help determine base material assessment and specifications. |
Returning to the original question: should you look at the base material or the load first? The answer is the base material. The base material determines 'whether it can be used,' the load determines 'what size is needed,' and the environment and installation conditions determine 'how it is installed.' Following the three steps in order largely avoids rework in selection; reversing the order means optimizing within the wrong set of candidates, no matter how precise the calculations. Daring mechanical anchors form a complete product system comprising undercut anchors, self-undercutting anchors, drop-in anchors, Anka anchors, and heavy-duty mechanical anchors, using carbon steel/stainless steel with multiple coating processes and mechanical locking for immediate lock-up on installation with no curing required, supported by complete technical documentation including ETA certification, Class S certification, and seismic test reports for a rare earthquake of intensity 9. For anchor selection and base material assessment support for specific projects, please consult the Daring technical team.
References
JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures — provisions on design service life and anchor selection for post-installed anchoring
GB 50367-2013 Design Code for Strengthening Concrete Structures — anchor selection and detailing requirements for load-bearing structures
JG/T 160-2017 Mechanical Anchors for Concrete — classification, performance classes, and test methods for mechanical anchors
GB 50981-2014 Code for Seismic Design of Building Mechanical and Electrical Engineering — anchoring requirements for mechanical and electrical supports and hangers
Daring website — Undercut anchors or chemical anchors? A complete guide to selection
Daring website — Mechanical anchor product ranges and parameters
