Product Knowledge

Why Do Ordinary Expansion Anchors Split Concrete? An In-Depth Look at the Zero Expansion Stress Principle of Undercut Anchors

Views: 0Posted on: 2026-09-28

The bottom line first: The root cause of ordinary expansion anchors splitting concrete lies in their its friction anchoring principle itself — during installation the cone head squeezes the expansion sleeve to expand it radially, applying enormous radial expansion stress to the hole wallradial expansion stress. This stress has two fatal directions: one isoutward, pushing against the concrete and directly forming splitting cracks when the edge distance or spacing is insufficient; the other isinward squeezing the hole wall and generating circumferential tensile stress inside the concrete; when that stress exceeds the concrete’s tensile strength, microcracks extend outward from the hole wall. In anchor groups, the expansion stresses of multiple anchors superimpose, multiplying the risk of splitting failure along the line between anchors. Undercut anchors are entirely different — a reverse-cone cavity is pre-cut at the hole bottom, and the anchor’s expansion element opens inside the cavity to form mechanical interlock; the cavity provides space to accommodate expansion deformation, so the anchor’s radial pressure on the hole wall approaches zero — this is the essence of “zero expansion stress”. According to JGJ 145-2013 and GB 50367-2013, load-bearing structures must use undercut anchors or special reverse-cone chemical anchors, and ordinary expansion anchors are strictly prohibited in load-bearing structures, cracked concrete, and seismic fortification zones. Daring undercut anchors have passed more than ten tests including S-class anchor certification, 2 million cycles of fatigue testing, 120 minutes of fire resistance, and seismic testing, making them a compliant choice for load-bearing structure anchoring.

Ordinary expansion anchors are extremely widely used on job sites because they install easily and cost little. But a fact repeatedly confirmed by numerous engineering accidents is that the anchoring principle of expansion anchors itself gives them an inherent destructive tendency toward concrete base materials. The collapse of a cooling water pipeline at Changshu Wanda Plaza killed 3 people, and a falling large steel billboard beside a street caused 3 deaths and 7 injuries — behind these major accidents, splitting failure of expansion anchors was the common fatal link. This article deeply analyzes, at the level of mechanics, why ordinary expansion anchors split concrete and how undercut anchors eliminate this hazard in principle.

I. The anchoring principle of ordinary expansion anchors: the inherent flaw of friction anchoring

1.1 Working principle — anchoring force from “expanding”

The anchoring principle of the ordinary expansion anchor can be summarized in one sentence: it resists pull-out through the friction generated by radial squeezing of the hole wall. During installation, applied torque pulls the nut and moves the threaded rod outward; the cone head at the rod’s bottom squeezes the expansion sleeve so it expands radially and presses tightly against the hole wall. The hole wall’s reaction force on the expansion sleeve forms frictional resistance that prevents the anchor from being pulled out.

This principle carries an unavoidable physical fact: the anchoring force depends directly on the radial pressure the expansion sleeve applies to the hole wall. Greater pressure means greater friction and higher anchoring force. But that radial pressure is simultaneously pushing against the concrete of the hole wall — the greater the pressure, the higher the risk of the concrete being split open. This is an irreconcilable contradiction and the root of the expansion anchor’s inherent flaw.

1.2 Installation stage: generation of radial expansion stress

At the installation stage, an expansion anchor already applies initial radial expansion stress to the concrete. Anchor product standards require the installation torque of expansion anchors to be strictly controlled within the specified range, because the installation torque directly determines the initial radial pressure the expansion sleeve applies to the hole wall. When the installation torque is excessive, the cone head is pulled too far, the sleeve over-expands, and the radial stress rises sharply. With insufficient edge distance or low base material strength, this initial stress alone can cause the concrete to develop installation splitting — the concrete has already cracked before the pull-out test even begins.

According to JGJ 145-2013, the minimum edge distance c_min, minimum spacing s_min, and minimum base material thickness h_min at which no splitting failure occurs during anchor installation should be determined from the anchor product’s certification report. Expansion anchors are highly sensitive to these parameters, because their radial stress acts on the concrete continuously from the moment installation is completed.

1.3 Tension stage: superposition of radial stress and tensile force

When an expansion anchor bears external tension, the radial expansion stress not only does not decrease but increases with the tensile force. Research shows that the splitting force (Spaltkraft) of metal expansion anchors is proportional to the applied tensile force — the greater the tension, the stronger the cone head squeezes the expansion sleeve and the greater the radial expansion stress.

This means the stress state of an expansion anchor is a vicious cycle: external tension ↑ → cone head squeezing of the expansion sleeve ↑ → radial expansion stress ↑ → circumferential tensile stress in the hole wall concrete ↑ → splitting risk ↑. Under normal working loads, this superposition effect may not yet be enough to crack the concrete; but under extreme conditions such as wind vibration, earthquakes, or impact, tension rises suddenly, the radial expansion stress soars with it, and the concrete can split in an instant.

II. Two mechanical paths of splitting concrete

2.1 Path one: outward pushing — splitting at concrete edges

When an anchor is located close to the edge of a concrete member, the component of the radial stress that the expansion sleeve exerts on the hole wall and that points toward the outside of the member pushes against the concrete edge. If the edge distance \( c \) is smaller than the critical edge distance \( c_{cr,sp} \) (usually taken as \( 1.5h_{ef} \) or greater), the radial thrust generates tensile stress in the concrete edge; when that tensile stress exceeds the tensile strength of the concrete, cracks begin to extend from the hole wall toward the member edge in the form ofradial cracks; in severe cases the concrete edge breaks away directly.

This failure can occur as early as the installation stage, showing up as fine cracks around the hole wall and chipping or spalling at the corners of the member. Under tension, an expansion anchor with insufficient edge distance will fail by edge splitting at loads far below the design load, with its load capacity substantially reduced.

2.2 Path two: inward compression — cracking from circumferential tensile stress

Even when the anchor is far from the member edge, the radial expansion stress will still generatecircumferential tensile stress around the hole wall. From a mechanics standpoint, when the hole wall is subjected to outward radial pressure, the concrete around the hole behaves like a ring being stretched from within, with the inner wall in compression and the outer wall in tension. When the circumferential tensile stress exceeds the tensile strength of the concrete, fine cracks extend outward from the hole wall asradial micro-cracks。

. In their initial stage these micro-cracks are usually difficult to detect with the naked eye, but they pose a fatal threat to the long-term safety of the anchoring system. Under vibration, temperature cycling and loading, the micro-cracks keep propagating until the anchoring force is completely lost — the anchor is pulled out of the hole, leaving behind only an enlarged hole in the concrete surface.

2.3 The group anchor effect: the amplification mechanism of splitting failure

The radial expansion stress of a single expansion anchor is already enough to pose a threat, and in an anchor group the expansion stresses of multiple anchors willsuperimpose on one another. According to the classification in JGJ 145-2013, when an anchor group is in tension, the expansion force exerted by the anchors on the concrete produces, along the line connecting the anchors,splitting failure which is one of the four principal forms of concrete failure in the base material for expansion-type anchors and undercut-type anchors. When the anchor spacing \( s \) is smaller than the critical spacing \( s_{cr,sp} \), the expansion stresses of adjacent anchors superimpose, forming a zone of concentrated tensile stress along the line between two anchors, and the concrete splits along that line.

The consequences of this splitting failure are catastrophic: once the line connecting the anchors is split through, the anchoring force of the entire anchor group is lost simultaneously and the fixed component falls away instantly. Investigations of engineering accidents have shown that in many falls caused by expansion anchors, the failure mode was splitting of the anchor group along the connecting line.

3. An in-depth breakdown of the "zero expansion stress" principle of undercut anchors

3.1 The core structural difference — an extra "cavity" at the bottom of the hole

The most fundamental difference between undercut anchors and ordinary expansion anchors lies in the shape of the hole. Installing an undercut anchor takes two steps: the first step is drilling a straight hole with a hammer drill, and the second step usesa special reaming drill bit to ream the bottom of the hole in a second operation, formingan inverted-cone cavity that is larger at the bottom and narrower at the top. The reamed cavity and the opened key segments of the anchor together form an interlocking mechanism.

The existence of this inverted-cone cavity fundamentally changes the way the anchor carries load. In an ordinary expansion anchor, the expansion sleeve is expanded ina straight hole of constant diameter; the sleeve is pressed against the hole wall, and the expansion force, with nowhere else to go, acts entirely on the hole wall. In an undercut anchor, however, the expansion elements open inan undercut cavity of larger diameter, and the cavity provides the space needed to accommodate the expansion deformation.

3.2 Mechanical interlock — an essential upgrade from "friction" to "positive engagement"

The source of anchoring force in an undercut anchor isfundamentally different from that in an expansion anchor. An expansion anchor relies on thefriction between the expansion sleeve and the hole wall — a single friction surface that depends on normal force and the friction coefficient. An undercut anchor relies on themechanical interlock formed between the expansion segments and the reamed cavity at the bottom of the hole: once the segments open, they are wedged inside the inverted-cone cavity, and to pull the anchor out, the segments would have to be "sheared" out of the cavity or the cavity ledge would have to "crumble" away, which means overcoming theshear strength of the concrete rather than friction alone.

From a mechanics standpoint, the load capacity of a mechanical interlock (volumetric engagement) is far higher than that of friction expansion (surface contact). This is because the shear strength of concrete is far higher than its friction-based load capacity, and volumetric engagement is unaffected by construction factors such as hole wall smoothness or residual dust. In Daring undercut anchors, the undercut cavity and the expansion segments of the anchor forma continuous circumferential undercut supporting expansion ring cut into the concrete surface that prevents pull-out, which provides a large interlock area and a uniform stress distribution and is the key to achieving high load capacity and seismic performance.

3.3 The mechanical essence of "zero expansion stress"

Undercut anchors are described as having "zero expansion stress", and their mechanical essence can be understood on the following three levels:

  • Level one — deformation space releases radial stress: the expansion segments open inside the undercut cavity, whose radial dimensions are larger than those of the straight-hole section, giving the segments enough space to complete their expansion deformation. The radial pressure generated when the segments contact the cavity wall is distributed overthe entire inner surface of the cavity instead of being concentrated on the narrow hole wall of the straight-hole section. The radial stress per unit area is greatly reduced, and the damage to the concrete is significantly diminished.

  • Level two — the mechanical interlock replaces friction anchoring: the anchoring force no longer depends on the friction generated by radial pressure, but on the mechanical engagement between the expansion segments and the cavity ledge. The installation torque only needs to be sufficient to open the segments fully, far less than the "tightening" torque required by expansion anchors. This substantial reduction in torque requirement also means far less initial stress disturbance to the concrete during installation.

  • Level three — the tension load path changes: when an expansion anchor is under tension, the cone head squeezes the expansion sleeve further, and the radial stress increases in proportion to the tensile load. When an undercut anchor is under tension, the tension is transferred directly through the expansion segments to the cavity ledge via aaxial-shear path rather than aradial-friction path. An increase in tension does not increase the radial stress, fundamentally severing the failure chain of "tension → radial stress → splitting".

3.4 Effect on initial stress in the concrete base material

Undercut anchors impose low initial stress on the concrete base material and suit small edge distances and spacings. This trait directly resolves the core pain point of expansion anchors regarding edge distance and spacing. Under the same edge distance conditions, undercut anchors can be used safely while expansion anchors may already be in the splitting risk zone.

Undercut anchors suit cracked and non-cracked concrete base materials from C20 to C60. In cracked concrete, expansion anchors face an insurmountable dilemma — when a crack opens, the sleeve’s expansion force is “consumed” by the opening, the anchor cannot expand further, and the anchoring force drops sharply until it is completely lost. The undercut anchor’s mechanical interlock does not rely on expansion force, and crack opening does not weaken the engagement between the expansion segments and the undercut cavity, so it maintains stable anchoring performance even in cracked concrete.

IV. Comparison summary of the two anchor types

Comparison dimensionOrdinary expansion anchorUndercut anchor
Anchoring principleFriction anchoring — friction generated by radial squeezingMechanical interlock — loads transferred by geometric engagement
Radial expansion stressLarge, and increasing with tensile force (proportional relationship)Near zero; the undercut cavity releases deformation space
Installation torque requirementHigh; it must be “expanded tight” to anchorLow; the expansion segments only need to open into place
Splitting riskHigh; splits readily when edge distance/spacing is insufficientLow; suits small edge distances and spacings
Suitability for cracked concreteNot suitable — crack opening causes loss of anchoring forceSuitable — the mechanical interlock does not rely on expansion force
Seismic performanceCapacity drops markedly under dynamic loadsCapacity essentially unchanged under dynamic loads
Failure modeProne to pull-out or splitting failure (brittle)Anchor steel fracture or concrete cone failure (ductile)
Code complianceStrictly prohibited in load-bearing structures, cracked concrete, and seismic zonesOne of the only compliant choices for load-bearing structures

V. Code basis and engineering application requirements

5.1 Mandatory code requirements

According to JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures and GB 50367-2013 Design Code for Strengthening Concrete Structures, load-bearing structure anchoring must use undercut anchors or special reverse-cone chemical anchors, and ordinary expansion anchors are strictly prohibited in load-bearing structures. In seismic fortification zones, on cracked concrete base materials, and under small edge distance/small spacing conditions, the undercut anchor is the only compliant mechanical anchor choice.

Anchors for fixed supports should be undercut anchors of grade 8.8 or higher, with hot-dip galvanizing at least 50μm thick, and should be models suitable for cracked concrete and able to withstand seismic action, with the relevant type test reports or seismic performance test reports provided.

5.2 Product fit of Daring undercut anchors

The Daring undercut anchor series covers M8-M20 sizes, with materials including grade 5.8 and grade 8.8 carbon steel (hot-dip galvanized ≥45μm) and 304/316 stainless steel, plus original-equipment undercut drill bits and electric installation tools. Daring undercut anchors have passed S-class anchor certification, 2 million cycles of fatigue testing, 120 minutes of fire resistance, seismic testing, coating thickness inspection, and salt spray testing and more than ten other authoritative tests. With materials covering grade 5.8/8.8 carbon steel and 304/316 stainless steel, they are a compliant choice for load-bearing structure anchoring. Daring self-undercutting anchors achieve pull-out forces above 50kN and perform even better under vibration and impact loads.

VI. Frequently asked questions

Q1Why do ordinary expansion anchors split concrete?
Expansion anchors anchor by generating friction through radial squeezing of the hole wall. During installation the cone head squeezes the expansion sleeve, applying enormous radial expansion stress to the hole wall. When edge distance or spacing is insufficient, the radial stress pushes the concrete outward and forms splitting cracks; even away from edges, the radial stress creates circumferential tensile stress around the hole wall, forming microcracks once it exceeds the concrete’s tensile strength. In anchor groups, the expansion stresses of multiple anchors superimpose, multiplying the risk of splitting along the line between anchors.
Q2Why do undercut anchors have no expansion stress?
An undercut anchor pre-cuts a reverse-cone cavity at the hole bottom, and the expansion element opens within this cavity to form the mechanical interlock. The cavity provides space to accommodate expansion deformation, distributing the radial pressure over the entire inner surface of the cavity and greatly reducing the stress per unit area. The anchoring force no longer relies on friction from radial pressure but on the mechanical engagement between the expansion segments and the cavity’s step; the tension transfer path changes from radial-friction to axial-shear, eliminating expansion stress at its root.
Q3What is the relationship between splitting force and tensile force for expansion anchors?
Research shows that the splitting force of metal expansion anchors is proportional to the applied tensile force. The greater the tension, the stronger the cone head squeezes the expansion sleeve and the greater the radial expansion stress. This means the stress state of an expansion anchor is a vicious cycle: external tension increases → radial stress increases → splitting risk rises. Under extreme conditions such as wind-induced vibration and earthquakes, this superimposed effect is especially dangerous.
Q4Can undercut anchors be used in cracked concrete?
Yes. Expansion anchors face an insurmountable dilemma in cracked concrete — when cracks open, the expansion force is consumed and the anchoring force drops sharply until it is lost. The undercut anchor’s mechanical interlock does not rely on expansion force, and crack opening does not weaken the engagement between the expansion segments and the undercut cavity, so it maintains stable anchoring performance in cracked concrete. It suits cracked and non-cracked concrete base materials from C20 to C60.
Q5Can ordinary expansion anchors be used in load-bearing structures?
No. According to JGJ 145-2013 and GB 50367-2013, load-bearing structure anchoring must use undercut anchors or special reverse-cone chemical anchors, and ordinary expansion anchors are strictly prohibited in load-bearing structures, cracked concrete, and seismic fortification zones. Anchors for fixed supports should be undercut anchors of grade 8.8 or higher, with test reports proving suitability for cracked concrete and seismic use.
Q6How do failure modes differ between undercut anchors and ordinary expansion anchors?
Expansion anchors are prone to pull-out or splitting failure — brittle failures with large scatter in failure loads and unpredictable capacity. The ideal failure modes of undercut anchors are anchor steel fracture or concrete cone failure — ductile failures with warning that can be calculated. In seismic tests, the ultimate capacity of undercut anchors is essentially unaffected by dynamic loading, while that of expansion anchors drops markedly under dynamic loads.

The Daring mechanical anchor series covers undercut, self-undercutting, drop-in, Anka, and heavy-duty mechanical anchors, among other types. Made of carbon steel or stainless steel with multi-layer coating processes, they achieve mechanical interlocking that locks immediately upon installation without curing, and suit cracked and non-cracked concrete, natural stone, and many other base materials. Daring undercut anchors have passed more than ten authoritative tests including S-class anchor certification, 2 million cycles of fatigue testing, 120 minutes of fire resistance, and seismic testing. For mechanical anchor selection and scheme design guidance on specific projects, contact the Daring technical team.

References

JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures — anchorage failure types, edge distance and spacing requirements

GB 50367-2013 Design Code for Strengthening Concrete Structures — provisions on the keying effect of undercut anchors

JG/T 160-2017 Mechanical Anchors for Concrete — classification and technical requirements for mechanical anchors

Daring official website — Mechanical anchor classification explained: understanding the differences between undercut, self-undercutting, and expansion anchors

Daring official website — Why are undercut anchors safer than both chemical and expansion anchors? Five core advantages explained at once

Daring official website — What is the difference between undercut anchors and self-undercutting anchors? How to choose, explained in one article

Daring official website — Mechanical anchor product series

Back to Daring Home  Back to Top