Product Knowledge

Is Curtain Wall Anchoring Governed by Seismic or Wind Loads? Load Combinations and How to Tell

Views: 0Posted on: 2026-10-23

The conclusion first:The vast majority of curtain-wall anchoring projectsControlled by wind load, because wind is a long-term repetitive action that directly determines anchor specifications and point density; but the seismic load case cannot be omitted, as it determinesDisplacement accommodation capacity, and cannot be covered simply by 'taking the larger of the two'. The judgment method is straightforward: calculate the wind-induced internal force per anchor and the internal force per anchor under seismic action separately, divide each by the corresponding design load capacity to obtain the utilization ratio,The load case with the higher utilization ratio is the controlling case; at the same time, the deformation allowance of connections under inter-story drift must be checked separately. Projects with a height exceeding 100 m, a fortification intensity of 8 or above, and large panels with relatively low wind pressure tend to shift from wind control to displacement (seismic) control.

Scope of application:This article addresses the anchorage nodes between building curtain-wall panels and their supporting structures (back bolts, pendants, cast-in channels, and post-installed anchors), discussing the identification and combination of two load cases: wind load and seismic action. The seismic calculation of the main structure itself, the section design of curtain-wall framing, and the strength verification of glass panels are outside the scope of this article.

There are two common misconceptions on site, pointing in opposite directions. One is "as long as the wind load is calculated properly, that's enough", on the grounds that the curtain wall hangs on the wall and sways with the main structure during an earthquake, so the anchors carry no additional load. The other is "seismic design requires a magnification factor", so a factor of 1.3 or 1.5 is applied to the wind load result, assuming this covers seismic effects as well. Both approaches are wrong in the same way:treating seismic design as a "force", when what seismic design truly requires is "deformation capacity"。

Under a rare earthquake, the main structure develops inter-storey drift, and the curtain wall, as a non-structural component, is forced to follow. At this point the anchorage connection carries not only inertial force but alsothe forced relative displacement. If the slotted holes in the pendants are too short, the sliding movement of the channels is insufficient, or the clearance around the back bolts is blocked, the connection will be sheared off or pulled out during displacement — this process has little to do with "whether the force is large enough" and a great deal to do with "whether it can yield". This is why a magnification factor alone can never solve the seismic problem.

1. Clarifying the essential difference between the two load cases

1.1 Wind is long-term and repetitive; earthquakes are rare, one-off events

Wind load is characterized byhigh frequency, long duration, variable direction. A 100 m-high curtain wall experiences millions of fluctuating wind cycles over a 50-year design life. The real test under the wind load case is therefore fatigue: whether the stress amplitude is within the material's fatigue limit and whether the anchor has verification data for 2 million cycles. Seismic action is characterized bylow frequency, rare occurrence, large single displacement, and may not occur at all in 50 years, but when it does, the displacement far exceeds normal levels. The two impose completely different performance requirements on anchors.

1.2 Why "taking the larger value as an envelope" gives the wrong result

Enveloping presupposes that the two load cases act on the same physical quantity. Wind and earthquakes do both produce force and displacement, but theirtime scales differ by two orders of magnitude: plotting the peak seismic force and the peak wind force on the same graph to compare magnitudes yields a conclusion with no engineering meaning. More importantly, fatigue accumulation under the wind load case and displacement demand under the seismic case are two verification lines that cannot replace each other. If the former fails, anchors loosen after some years; if the latter fails, panels fall during an earthquake. The probability of both failing is not high, but passing one does not mean passing the other.

The approach in actual engineering practice is:verify load capacity under the unfavourable combination, verify displacement separately under the seismic load case, and verify fatigue separately under the wind load case. The three tracks proceed independently, and the final solution must satisfy all of them. This is why a professional curtain-wall calculation report shows three sets of figures for the same back bolt, rather than a single "controlling internal force".

2. Three-step identification: Which one actually controls

2.1 Step 1: Calculate the wind-induced internal force in a single anchor

Starting from the basic wind pressure, apply the shape coefficient, height variation coefficient, and gust factor to obtain the standard wind load on the envelope, then multiply by the area carried by a panel to obtain the wind force on that panel, and finally distribute it among the anchors according to the number of points. The most common problem here iscorner and eaves areas: the negative pressure shape coefficient is significantly amplified at corners, where local wind pressure can be more than twice that of standard areas. If a single average wind pressure is used for the whole wall, corners are inevitably under-designed.

2.2 Step 2: Calculate the internal force in a single anchor under seismic action

As a non-structural component, the curtain wall's seismic action is calculated as its own weight multiplied by the seismic influence coefficient, which depends on the fortification intensity, site category, and component location (floor amplification). The calculation itself is not complicated; what is complicated isthe dynamic amplification at connection nodes: local amplification often occurs where components connect to the main structure, and codes specify corresponding amplification requirements for the support points of non-structural components. The force calculated at this step is usually smaller than the wind load, which is the source of the "wind-controlled" conclusion.

2.3 Step 3: Compare utilization ratios, then check displacement separately

Divide the two internal forces by the design load capacity of the anchorage under the corresponding load case to obtain two utilization ratios. The larger one indicates the load-capacity-controlling case. But the identification does not end here — a displacement check is also required:Inter-storey drift ratio of the main structure × storey height = relative displacement of the connection, and this displacement must be less than the total deformation allowance provided by pendant slotted holes, channel sliding movement, and back bolt clearance. In many projects the load capacity utilization ratio is only 0.5 while displacement is already locked up; in such cases the controlling case should be identified as seismic (displacement) control.

StepCalculation contentKey inputIdentification action
Step 1Wind-induced internal force in a single anchorBasic wind pressure, shape coefficient, height coefficient, gust factor, tributary areaCalculated by zones, with corners and eaves taken separately
Step 2Seismic internal force per anchorFortification intensity, site category, component self-weight, location amplificationCalculate as a non-structural component, taking into account support-point amplification
Step 3Compare utilization ratiosDesign load capacity under both load casesThe load case with the higher utilization ratio is the load-capacity-controlled case
Step 4Displacement checkInter-story drift ratio, story height, connection deformation allowanceIf the allowance is insufficient, the case is judged as displacement-controlled
Step 5Fatigue checkWind-induced stress amplitude, number of cyclesMandatory for high-rise buildings and high-wind regions

III. How to use combination factors

3.1 Load capacity combinations: wind is the main action, seismic is an accidental action

Load capacity verification of curtain wall components usually considerspermanent load + wind load + temperature actionas the fundamental combination, with seismic action verified separately as an accidental combination. When combining, two sets of values must be distinguished: standard values and design values. Standard values are used for deformation and displacement verification, while design values are used for load capacity verification. Mixing up the two sets is a frequent reason why calculation reports are returned for revision.

3.2 Why the seismic load case is often verified separately rather than included in the main combination

Because seismic action is a rare event, the probability of it reaching its peak simultaneously with wind load is extremely low. Including it in the main combination would lead to unnecessary increases in the specifications of all components, raising costs with only limited safety benefits. Separate verification, on the other hand, allows control through displacement and detailing measures under the logic that 'local plastic deformation is permitted during an earthquake, but no falling is allowed'. This is the very reason anti-fall systems exist: they do not increase load capacity, but provide a second line of protection.

Load caseNatureIncluded in fundamental combinationMain verification target
Self-weight (permanent)Long-term constantYespendant support, back bolt shear
Wind loadLong-term cyclic, variableYes (main variable load)Load capacity + fatigue
Temperature actionCyclicYes (by combination factor)Panel joint deformation, connector displacement
Seismic actionRare, transientUsually verified separately as an accidental combinationDisplacement accommodation, anti-fall

IV. Height × fortification intensity: which factor controls

The matrix below is an empirical summary for quick judgment at the scheme design stage and cannot replace a calculation report. To use it: first locate the cell corresponding to the project, then decide whether to focus subsequent efforts on load capacity optimization or displacement detailing.

Building heightIntensity 6Intensity 7Intensity 8Intensity 9
≤50mWind-controlledWind-controlledWind-controlled; displacement must be checkedDual control by load capacity and displacement
50~100mWind-controlledWind-controlled; fatigue must be checkedMainly wind-controlled, with displacement check as the key issueDisplacement-controlled
100~200mWind-controlled, with fatigue as the focusWind-controlled; 2 million cycles verification requiredDual control by wind and displacementDisplacement-controlled; anti-fall system essential
>200mWind-controlled, with wind-induced vibration and fatigue both importantDual control by wind and displacementDual control; special seismic review requiredDisplacement-controlled; special review required

"Displacement-controlled" in the table does not mean load capacity is unimportant; rather, it meansraising the load capacity by another step will not solve the problem— one must return to the detailing and provide deformation allowance. Conversely, for a project in a "wind-controlled" cell, focusing mainly on seismic coefficients is equally misdirected.

5. What seismic design truly requires: Displacement and detailing

5.1 The inter-storey drift ratio is the starting point

The inter-storey drift limit of the main structure depends on the structural type and differs for frame, frame-shear wall, and shear wall structures. Multiply the calculated drift ratio by the storey height to obtain the relative displacement of that storey. Curtain-wall connections must be able to absorb this displacement without generating restraint reactions; otherwise the curtain wall acts as a "diagonal brace", transferring load back into the main structure and damaging both.

5.2 Where does the deformation allowance come from

There are three sources of allowance:The sliding movement of the slotted holes in pendants、The sliding travel of T-head bolts in channels、The clearance between back bolts and hole walls. Only the combination of the three constitutes the total deformation capacity of a connection. A common error is to make the slotted hole exactly equal to the calculated displacement, leaving no allowance for construction tolerances or thermal movement; the correct approach is to provide a clear margin of safety and ensure that the bolt does not lock up during sliding due to excessive torque.

Detailing measureDeformation capacity providedFailure modeKey control points
Pendant slotted holeSliding along the long direction of the holeInsufficient hole length, bolt locking upAllow clearance in the hole; control torque within upper and lower limits
Cast-in channelT-head bolt sliding along the channelTeeth jamming, no travel at the endReserve travel at the ends; match tooth profile to the bolt
Clearance between back bolt and hole wallSlight rotation and translationHole position deviation consuming the clearanceAccuracy in setting out hole positions; avoid forcing holes into alignment
Anti-fall systemDoes not provide displacement; provides secondary restraintConnection point looseningConnected independently to the main structure, with freedom of movement

6. Common misconceptions: Five actions that miscalculate load cases

SymptomConsequenceCorrect approach
Using a single average wind pressure for the entire wallNegative wind pressure at corners and eaves is under-designed, so local panels can fall easilyDivide into zones by shape coefficient; calculate corners separately
Using "wind load × 1.3" in place of seismic designDisplacement demand is not covered and the connection may still shear offCalculate seismic action separately for non-structural components and check displacement
Performing only load capacity verification, without displacement checkingLow utilization yet locking up during an earthquakeVerify displacement and load capacity along two parallel tracks
Sizing slotted holes to "exactly" match the calculated displacementNo allowance left after construction tolerances and thermal movement are addedProvide a clear safety margin and control bolt torque
No fatigue check for high-rise projectsAnchors loosen and pendants wear under long-term wind-induced vibrationRequire verification data for 2 million cycles

7. Daring's support for these two load cases

The wind load case is about load capacity and fatigue, while the seismic case is about certification and displacement. Daring back bolts, undercut anchors, and Anka anchors have all passed EU ETA certification and hold Class S certification and a Tongji University rare-earthquake seismic test report at intensity 9 (test acceleration up to 1.24g); back bolts also have data from 2 million fatigue cycles and salt spray tests, which can be used directly as calculation values and for expert review. As secondary protection, the panel anti-fall system is connected independently of the back bolt system and serves as a backup if displacement control fails.

ProductMaterialSpecificationSurface treatmentApplicable load caseCertification and testingSupporting tools
Back bolt304/316 stainless steelM6、M8Natural / passivatedWind load, fatigue, seismicETA, intensity 9 rare earthquake, salt sprayDrilling machine, hole gauge rod, hole gauge
Undercut anchorGalvanized carbon steel / stainless steelM8~M16Hot-dip galvanizedSeismic, dynamic loadETA, Class SUndercutting drill bit, pull-out tester
Cast-in channelCarbon steel / stainless steelSingle C, double CHot-dip galvanizedDisplacement accommodation, heavy loadsLoad capacity testingT-head bolt, positioning accessories
Panel anti-fall systemStainless steelMatched to panel typeNaturalSecondary protection under a rare earthquakeMechanical property testingDedicated connector

Load capacity, fatigue stress amplitude, and displacement allowance for specific specifications are subject to the product parameter table and type test report. When making a preliminary assessment, one can first remember this sequence:first determine load capacity from wind pressure and height, then determine displacement demand from seismic intensity and storey height, and finally use certification data to check whether both are covered。

8. Frequently asked questions

Q1Should curtain-wall anchorage be designed for seismic action or wind load?
Both must be calculated, but for different purposes: wind load determines load capacity and fatigue, while seismic action determines displacement accommodation. To judge which one "controls", compare the utilization ratio, not the absolute value of internal force.
Q2For a 100 m-high curtain wall in an intensity-8 zone, which usually controls?
Generally, wind still controls load capacity, but the displacement check is often the real bottleneck. A common situation in such projects is a load capacity utilization ratio below 0.6 while the slotted hole travel is already insufficient.
Q3Can a factor be applied directly to the wind load result for the seismic load case?
No. Seismic action is a different physical process, and its core requirement is displacement capacity. Multiplying by a factor changes only the force, not the deformation allowance of the connection.
Q4With an inter-storey drift ratio of 1/550 and a storey height of 4.2 m, how much displacement should the connection allow?
The relative displacement is on the order of 7.6 mm; the total deformation allowance of the connection should include a margin on top of this, with construction tolerances and thermal movement also taken into account. The specific value should follow the curtain-wall calculation report and pendant travel parameters.
Q5Can an anti-fall system replace seismic verification?
No. It is secondary protection whose role is to prevent panel fall when the main connection fails; it provides no load capacity and does not solve displacement restraint problems.
Q6Why must fatigue data be reviewed for high-rise projects?
Because wind-induced vibration is a long-term repetitive action, with millions of cycles over 50 years. Without verification data at the level of 2 million cycles, it is impossible to judge whether the anchor will loosen or crack under long-term stress amplitude.

The conclusion can be summed up in one sentence:Wind determines "whether it is strong enough"; earthquakes determine "whether it can yield". The former relies on load capacity and fatigue data, the latter on displacement allowance and detailing; the two tracks cannot replace each other or be converted into one another by factors. At the concept stage, first identify the controlling type from height and intensity, then decide where to focus design effort — far more effective than blindly increasing specifications. Daring can provide complete certification documents and calculation parameters for back bolts, undercut anchors, cast-in channels, and anti-fall systems, supporting curtain-wall calculation values and special seismic review. For load case identification and connection displacement checking for a specific project, please consult the Daring technical team.

References

GB 50009-2012 Load Code for the Design of Building Structures — Standard values of wind load and shape coefficients for envelope structures

GB 50011-2010 Code for Seismic Design of Buildings — Seismic action on non-structural components and inter-storey drift ratio limits

JGJ 102-2003 Technical Code for Engineering of Glass Curtain Walls — Load combinations and displacement control requirements

JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-installed Anchorage in Concrete Structures — Seismic and load capacity verification provisions for post-installed anchorage connections

Daring website — Guide to back bolt selection and layout for curtain walls in seismic fortification zones above intensity 8

Daring website — How to select back bolts for super-tall building curtain walls? Key points under wind load and seismic requirements

Daring website — A full analysis of the Daring back bolt certification system: ETA certification, rare-earthquake resistance at intensity 9, salt spray test

Daring website — Introduction to the Daring panel anti-fall system: dual protection for super-tall curtain walls

Daring website — Which is more important for chemical anchors, shear or tension? Selection logic for different load cases

Daring website — How to determine the effective embedment depth of undercut mechanical anchors

Disclaimer:The technical parameters, construction details, and assessment methods set out in this article are compiled on the basis of current national standards, industry codes, and product type test reports, and are provided as a reference for technical selection. The anchorage design, connection calculations, and acceptance criteria for a specific project should be reviewed and determined by a suitably qualified design institute in light of actual project conditions; actual product performance is subject to the parameter table and type test report for the corresponding batch. This article does not replace the design documents and technical agreement for a specific project.

Back to Daring Home  Back to Top