Product Knowledge

How to Select the Safety Factor for Anchors? The Selection Logic of 2.0, 3.0 and Seismic Scenarios

Views: 0Posted on: 2026-10-23

Conclusion first:2.0 and 3.0 are not two interchangeable safety factors, but ratherproducts of different numerical bases— 2.0 is commonly found in the allowable stress approach of 'ultimate value ÷ overall safety factor', while 3.0 is common in systems where 'the design value already includes material and geometric partial factors'. There is only one correct approach:take the design value given in the type test or certification report, then apply site-condition reductions(base material strength, edge distance, spacing, temperature, long-term load); do not simply divide the ultimate pull-out force in a catalog by 2 or 3. The reliability under seismic load cases relies on displacement and cyclic verification, not on inflating factors.

Scope of application:This article discusses the logic of factors used to determine load capacity values for post-installed anchors in concrete (undercut, self-undercutting, chemical and expansion types), for design selection and drawing review. Strength verification of curtain wall panels, design of main structural members, and calculation of post-installed rebar embedment length are outside the scope of this article.

The most common misconception is that 'the larger the safety factor, the safer, so choosing 3.0 is always right'. This sounds prudent but actually leads the entire selection astray: to satisfy an inflated factor, the specification is forced up by one or two sizes, with greater drilling depth and larger edge distance requirements. On site, installation may then become impossible — insufficient edge distance, rebar obstruction, inadequate panel thickness — and in the end a smaller size has to be forced in, leaving the safety factor as a number on paper only.

The opposite mistake is 'copying factors directly'. Seeing 2.0 used in someone else's project, you write 2.0 too; seeing 'safety factor 3' in a catalog, you assume that product is safer. Both approaches skip the same question:what baseline this factor is applied to. With different baselines, the same number can represent a safety level that differs by a factor of two.

I. Three concepts that are commonly confused

1.1 Ultimate value, design value, allowable value

Ultimate valueis the maximum load at failure of a test specimen, representing the upper limit of material capacity;Design valueis derived from the ultimate value after applying material partial factors, geometric partial factors and statistical reductions, and can be compared directly with the design internal force;Allowable valueis the design value divided by a safety factor for the service stage, used in allowable stress design. The three form a chain, not parallel alternatives.

Confusing these three concepts leads to errors such as double calculation — 'ultimate value 60 kN, divided by 2 gives 30 kN, then multiplied by a load factor of 1.5'. In fact, 60 kN is already a characteristic value incorporating the statistical lower fractile; dividing and multiplying again amounts to counting the safety reserve twice.

1.2 Partial factors are not safety factors

Partial factors arebroken down by source of uncertainty: material strength scatter is covered by the material partial factor, geometric dimensional deviation by the geometric partial factor, and load uncertainty by the load partial factor. Their product constitutes the overall safety reserve, but each factor addresses one specific issue. By contrast, a 'safety factor' is a broad ratio that bundles all uncertainties together, making it impossible to identify the source of risk. This is why modern codes have replaced a single safety factor with a partial factor system — not because partial factors are more conservative, but because they are more traceable.

Numerical basisSourceCan it be compared directly with design internal forceCommon misuse
Ultimate value (failure load)Maximum measured value in tests or characteristic valueNoDirect comparison with design internal force, misjudging a large margin
Design valueGiven in the report, already includes partial factorsYesMultiplying by a safety factor again, resulting in double conservatism
Allowable valueDesign value divided by a service factorUsed only in allowable stress designMixed with design load values, resulting in a mismatch of bases
Safety factor 2.0/3.0Empirical ratio with no unified baselineDepends on which baseline it is applied toApplied directly without checking the baseline

II. Static load case: design value + five reductions

2.1 List of reduction items

The design value in a report usually corresponds to a set of standard conditions: reference concrete strength, minimum edge distance, minimum spacing, normal temperature and short-term load. If any condition on site deviates, a reduction is required. The most commonly overlooked of the five islong-term load— chemical anchors are subject to creep under sustained tension, and codes set specific requirements for long-term load cases; although mechanical anchors do not creep, loosening under long-term vibration must also be considered.

2.2 How reductions are combined

The common practice ismultiplication: the individual reduction factors are multiplied together to obtain an overall reduction. There is an easily overlooked trap here — correlations exist between reduction items. Low base material strength and small edge distance often occur together (thin panels, narrow beams), and multiplying the two factors separately may be overly conservative; conversely, treating them by 'taking the worst single item' underestimates the combined adverse effect. In engineering practice, multiplication is generally used, and at the scheme stage the number of reduction items is reduced by increasing the edge distance or changing the anchoring location, rather than simply accepting the factors.

Reduction itemTrigger conditionTreatmentRemarks
Base material strengthActual strength below the report referenceReduce by interpolation from the corresponding table in the reportBased on on-site rebound or test cube data
Edge distanceBelow the minimum edge distanceApply edge distance reduction or change the anchoring locationSmall edge distance is a frequent cause of failure
SpacingAnchor group spacing below the minimum spacingReduce according to group anchor effectOverlapping concrete failure cones
TemperatureChemical anchor service temperature outside the specified rangeReduce by temperature range or select a high-temperature-resistant adhesiveMechanical anchors are insensitive
Long-term loadSustained tension load caseReduce chemical anchors according to creep requirementsCurtain wall self-weight is a long-term load

III. Seismic load case: relies on displacement and cyclic behavior, not amplified factors

3.1 Why seismic performance must be assessed separately

Under seismic action, anchor behavior differs greatly from static loading: first,the concrete cracks at the same time, changing the load capacity baseline; second,there is reciprocating displacement, subjecting the anchor to repeated tension, compression and shear; third,the anchor may enter the plastic range, in which case the governing property is no longer strength but deformability. Therefore seismic performance cannot be covered by a single factor; it must be confirmed through dedicated assessment — in engineering practice this appears as seismic performance classes (such as C1 and C2) and markings such as Class S certification.

3.2 What rare-earthquake tests prove and what they do not

Rare-earthquake tests at intensity 9 (some products reach an acceleration of 1.24g) can prove that:under the specified seismic input and crack conditions, the anchor maintains the connection and does not fail by falling. What it cannot prove is that the anchor remains safe under conditions exceeding the test input, or that the same holds for other base material strengths and edge distances. When reading such reports, pay attention to three things: input acceleration, crack condition, and specimen edge distance and base material strength. If any of these three does not match your project, the report can only serve as a reference.

Load caseBasis for value selectionControlling parameterWhat must not be done
Static loadReport design value × reductionsLoad capacityDividing the ultimate value directly by a factor
seismicSeismic assessment + displacement checkDeformability, residual load capacityMultiplying an amplification factor onto static-load results
FatigueCyclic test (on the order of 2 million cycles)Stress amplitude, number of cyclesLooking only at peak values and not at amplitude

IV. Fatigue load case: look at stress amplitude, not peak value

4.1 Stress amplitude is the controlling quantity

Fatigue failure is determined bystress amplitude(the difference between the maximum and minimum values) andnumber of cyclestogether, and has little to do with the peak value itself. This point is often misunderstood: seeing that an anchor can withstand a static load of 40 kN, some people assume that a cyclic load of 20 kN under wind vibration is perfectly safe. In fact, if the stress amplitude is too high a proportion of the static capacity, cracks may appear after several hundred thousand cycles. The industry-standard verification method is 2 million load cycles, corresponding to the order of magnitude of wind-induced vibration cycles over a curtain wall's 50-year design life.

4.2 Preload changes the stress amplitude

One more point to note:preload changes the stress amplitude. With properly applied torque, the stress fluctuation in the anchor under cyclic load is compressed and fatigue life is extended; insufficient torque amplifies the stress amplitude and may also cause loosening. Therefore torque control is not only an installation quality issue, but also a fatigue issue.

4.3 Which projects require a fatigue check

Not every project requires one, but three types of project can hardly avoid it:high-rise and super-tall buildings(the number of wind-induced vibration cycles increases with height and structural frequency),high-wind regions and coastal typhoon-affected areas(large stress amplitude),lightweight large-panel curtain walls(low self-weight and a high proportion of wind load, giving more extreme stress fluctuation ratios). Conversely, for low-rise projects with thick panels and a high proportion of self-weight, the wind-induced stress amplitude is relatively small, so conventional static-load control can be used and efforts focused on load capacity.

A single ratio is enough to decide whether a fatigue check is needed:wind-induced stress amplitude ÷ static design load capacity. The higher this ratio, the more likely fatigue is to become the controlling item. When the ratio is low, forcing a fatigue verification usually yields the conclusion of 'far below the limit', which provides no guidance for the scheme; when the ratio approaches the critical value, skipping it leaves the risk in place. The reason the industry uses 2 million cycles as a general verification level is that it covers wind-induced vibration cycles over the 50-year service life of most curtain wall projects, representing a conservative value that covers the majority of situations.

V. A sample calculation (with explicit assumptions)

Assumptions: C30 non-cracked concrete, anchor in tension, design internal force 12 kN, edge distance meets the minimum, normal temperature, short-term load. Consulting the report for a certain size of undercut anchor, the design tensile value under C30 conditions is 20 kN (this value is an example assumption; in practice the corresponding product report must be consulted). Reductions: base material conforms to the reference = 1.0, edge distance satisfied = 1.0, long-term load = 0.9, combined reduction 0.9, giving 18 kN after reduction and a utilization ratio of 12/18 ≈ 0.67, which is satisfactory.

StepContentValue (example)
1Design internal force12kN
2Design value from report (C30)20 kN (assumed)
3Combined reduction factor0.9
4Reduced load capacity18kN
5Utilization ratio0.67, satisfactory

If the approach of 'ultimate value 60 kN divided by 3.0' were used instead, the result would be 20 kN, seemingly similar to the above — but this is only a coincidence. Once the base material strength drops to C20 and the edge distance is reduced, the difference between the two approaches rapidly grows: the partial factor system can reflect this accurately through reduction factors, whereas dividing by 3 can only rely on a subjective additional discount.

5.1 Working in reverse: deriving the size from the internal force

In actual scheme design, the process often runs in the opposite direction: given the design internal force and site conditions, work out which size to select. The steps simply reverse the sample calculation above —first estimate a combined reduction factor, divide the design internal force by it to obtain the required nominal load capacity, then find the smallest size in the report that meets this value. A size selected this way is 'just adequate' rather than 'apparently safe'.

The most common mistake in reverse calculation is to decide the size first and then adjust the reduction factors to fit. For example, having decided to use M10, one might raise the long-term load factor from 0.9 to 0.95 and simply treat the edge distance reduction as 1.0 in order to make the verification pass. Such 'reverse number-fitting' shows no problem on the drawing, but conceals the real reduction items. The correct approach is that reduction factors are determined only by site conditions and the size is determined by calculation results; neither should be adjusted to accommodate the other.

There is another practical constraint: the size derived by reverse calculation mustfit in place. Panel thickness, edge distance, rebar position and member cross-section dimensions — if any one of these is unsatisfied, even the most reasonable calculation cannot be implemented. A complete selection therefore involves two rounds: the first round calculates the size from the internal force, and the second round checks constructability. Only when both rounds pass is the scheme valid. Doing only the first round produces attractive drawings but difficult site work.

VI. Common mistakes: five ways to misuse factors

SymptomConsequenceCorrect practice
Dividing the catalog ultimate value by 2 or 3Unclear basis and untraceable safety reserveUsing the report design value directly and then applying reductions
Multiplying a safety factor onto the design value againDouble conservatism, inflated sizes that cannot be installed on siteConfirm that the report design value already includes partial factors
Multiplying static-load results by 1.3 for seismicDisplacement capacity unverified; connections may still shear offHandle by seismic assessment and displacement check
Applying only one reduction factorUnderestimating combined adverse conditionsApply factors multiplicatively, or improve detailing to reduce the number of reduction items
Judging fatigue by peak valueStress amplitude exceeds limits, leading to long-term cracking and looseningCheck test data against stress amplitude + number of cycles

VII. What documents Daring can provide for value selection

Value selection ultimately comes down to documentation. Daring back bolts, undercut anchors and Anka anchors have passed EU ETA certification; undercut anchors and back bolts hold Class S certification and rare-earthquake (intensity 9) seismic test reports. The reports give corresponding design value ranges by size and base material strength and can be used directly in calculation reports. Selection calculation sheets, quality certificates and lists of matching tools are also provided, so that design institutes and supervision engineers can verify the basis for the selected values.

ProductMaterialSizeSurface treatmentBasis for value selectionCertification and testingMatching tools
Undercut anchorCarbon steel, zinc-plated / stainless steelM8~M16Hot-dip galvanizingETA design value tableETA, Class S, rare earthquake at intensity 9Undercutting drill bit, torque wrench, pull-out tester
Back bolt304/316 stainless steelM6、M8Natural / passivatedType test + fatigue dataETA, salt spray, 2 million cycles fatigueDrilling machine, hole-gauge rod, hole gauge
Chemical anchorZinc-plated threaded rod + adhesive capsuleM10~M16Zinc platingType test design valueType testHole-cleaning pump, adhesive dispenser, torque wrench
Cast-in channelCarbon steel / stainless steelSingle C, double CHot-dip galvanizingLoad capacity test reportLoad capacity and corrosion protection testingT-head bolt, torque wrench

No specific values are listed in the table because load capacity varies with size, base material strength and edge distance; any figure divorced from these conditions would be misleading. The correct approach is to obtain the report and look up the corresponding row for the project conditions, and, where necessary, have the manufacturer's technical team issue a selection calculation sheet.

VIII. Frequently asked questions

Q1Should the anchor safety factor be 2 or 3?
First ask what the baseline is. If you have an ultimate value, it must be converted using the code's allowable stress or partial factor system; if you have a report design value, you should not multiply by a safety factor again — only apply the site reductions.
Q2Why can't the pull-out force in a catalog simply be divided by 2?
Because catalog values are mostly ultimate values or measured values for a specific base material, without statistical reduction and without material and geometric partial factors. A figure obtained by simply dividing by 2 does not correspond to any code verification basis.
Q3Should the factor be increased for seismic load cases?
No. There is no need to rely on amplified factors. Seismic performance depends on seismic performance class assessment and displacement verification; no matter how large the factor, it cannot prevent a connection from being sheared off by forced displacement.
Q4Should curtain wall self-weight under sustained tension be reduced additionally?
Yes. Chemical anchors are subject to creep under sustained tension and must be reduced for the long-term load case; mechanical anchors do not creep, but attention must be paid to preload and vibration loosening.
Q5Can the worst single reduction factor be used instead of multiplying them?
Not recommended. When several adverse conditions occur together (thin panel + small edge distance + low strength), taking only the worst single item underestimates the risk. Multiplication is closer to the actual situation.
Q6How many years does a 2 million-cycle fatigue test correspond to?
Roughly the order of magnitude of wind-induced vibration cycles over a curtain wall's 50-year design life. The exact conversion depends on the local wind climate and structural frequency and cannot be generalized; it must be determined from the project's wind vibration calculation.

The question of factors is essentially about 'replacing one vague number with a traceable logic'. Ultimate values cannot be used directly, design values need no further discount, seismic cannot be handled by amplification, and fatigue cannot be judged by peak value — remember these four points and value selection will not go astray. What truly requires time is not choosing factors, butfaithfully reflecting site conditions in the reduction items: what the actual base material strength is, how many centimeters the edge distance really is, and whether the load is short-term or long-term. If these data are wrong, no matter how accurate the factors, they are meaningless. Daring can provide certified design value tables for each size, seismic and fatigue test reports, and selection calculation sheets to support item-by-item verification of the basis for values. If you need support with reduction calculations for specific load cases, please consult Daring's technical team.

References

JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-installed Anchoring of Concrete Structures — provisions on design load capacity and partial factors for post-installed anchors

GB 50009-2012 Load Code for the Design of Building Structures — load partial factors and combination factors

GB 50011-2010 Code for Seismic Design of Buildings — seismic action and seismic verification of non-structural components

GB 50367-2013 Code for Design of Strengthening Concrete Structure — verification of anchoring load capacity and detailing requirements

Daring website — Full analysis of design pull-out values and testing standards for chemical anchors

Daring website — What on-site tests are required after installing curtain wall back bolts? Pull-out test coverage and acceptance criteria

Daring website — How to choose among the top ten undercut anchor brands? ETA certification, seismic performance and material are the core criteria

Daring website — What is the installation torque for back bolts? How to control installation quality with a torque wrench

Daring website — Can mechanical and chemical anchors be used together? Design considerations

Daring website — How to determine the effective embedment depth of undercut mechanical anchors

Disclaimer:The technical parameters, detailing methods and judgment methods contained in this article are compiled on the basis of current national standards, industry codes and product type test reports, for reference in technical selection. The anchoring design, connection calculations and acceptance criteria for a specific project must be reviewed and determined by a qualified design institute in light of actual project conditions; actual product performance is subject to the parameter table and type test report for the corresponding batch. This article does not replace the design documents and technical agreements for a specific project.

Back to Daring Home  Back to Top