Product Knowledge

Is it feasible to mix Daring mechanical and chemical anchors? What to watch for in design

Views: 0Posted on: 2026-09-16

To state the conclusion first:Mixing Daring mechanical anchors and chemical anchors is in principle not permitted at the code level. According to Clause 4.3.6 of JGJ 145-2013, Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures, anchor groups should use anchors of the same type and same size. This provision is mandatory; drawing review and third-party pull-out testing uniformly reject mixed-type schemes. The core risk of mixing lies in the two anchor types differ fundamentally in failure mechanism and stiffness - mechanical anchors are highly rigid and take load instantly, while chemical anchor adhesive provides elastic buffering; under load, the stiffer mechanical anchors take the full tensile force first, chemical anchors are nearly unloaded, and the anchor group capacity in fact equals only that of the mechanical anchors alone, creating serious safety hazards. "Alternating arrangement" is allowed in only one special condition: Post-installed inserts requiring welding after positioning, mechanical undercut anchors should be used, or chemical anchors and mechanical anchors should be arranged alternately; however, for post-installed inserts in which chemical anchors exceed half, no welding may be performed on their components and connectors after positioning. Daring offers full product lines of both mechanical anchors and chemical anchors, and can provide compliant single-type anchoring solutions for different service conditions.

In post-installed anchoring work, designers often face a practical question: on the same post-installed insert, can mechanical anchors be used for part of it and chemical anchors for the rest? This question is especially common in curtain walls, equipment foundations, steel structure column bases, and similar scenarios. Drawing on code requirements, load-bearing mechanisms, design points, and construction practice, this article systematically analyzes the feasibility of mixing Daring mechanical anchors and chemical anchors and the related design considerations.

I. Explicit Code Provisions on Mixing Anchor Types

1.1 Core Code Provisions

According to Clause 4.3.6 of JGJ 145-2013, Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures:anchor groups should use anchors of the same type and same size。

The commentary on this clause states that strict requirements are imposed on the matched use of anchor products within an anchor group mainly because all current research findings and engineering experience are based on such requirements. The anchor arrangement given in this clause is consistent with the calculation methods in subsequent chapters; other arrangement types, lacking sufficient research and engineering experience, require more detailed analysis when applied.

This means the codes require anchor groups to use same-type, same-size anchors; mixing mechanical anchors and chemical anchors in the same anchor group is not allowed.

1.2 The Only Exception - Welding Operations

Some local codes contain a special exception. The Shanghai Technical Specification for Building Curtain Wall Engineering stipulates: post-installed inserts requiring welding after positioning should use mechanical undercut anchors, or chemical anchors and mechanical anchors arranged alternately. For post-installed inserts in which chemical anchors exceed half, no welding may be performed on their components and connectors after positioning.

The rationale behind this clause is that the chemical agents of chemical anchors are not heat resistant, and welding heat on post-installed inserts with chemical anchors directly affects their load-bearing capacity. Therefore, when welding is required after a post-installed insert is positioned, the code allows a scheme of "chemical anchors plus mechanical undercut anchors arranged alternately". Note, however, that this exception applies only to welding conditions, and chemical anchors must not exceed half.

II. Why Mixing Is Risky - Fundamental Differences in Load-Bearing Mechanisms

2.1 Different Failure Mechanisms

The failure mechanisms of mechanical anchors and chemical anchors differ fundamentally:

  • Mechanical anchors: generate anchoring force through hole-bottom interlock or expansion and compression; failure modes are usually steel failure or concrete cone failure, forming a rigid load-bearing system

  • Chemical anchors: generate anchoring force through adhesive bonding; failure modes may be mixed failure or adhesive debonding, and the adhesive provides a degree of elastic buffering

when the two anchor types are mixed and subjected to tensile loads, the failure mode of chemical anchors is inconsistent with that of other anchors, and their respective load capacities cannot be verified or calculated. Using different anchor types under such unclear load capacity conditions easily leads to uncontrollable problems.

2.2 Stiffness Differences Cause Uneven Load Distribution

This is the most serious problem with mixing. Mechanical anchors are highly rigid and take load instantly, while the adhesive of chemical anchors provides elastic buffering. Under loads and bending moments:

  • The stiffer mechanical anchors will take the full tensile/shear force first

  • Due to the elastic deformation of the adhesive, chemical anchors are nearly unloaded

  • The total capacity of the anchor group in fact equals only the capacity of the mechanical anchors alone

  • In earthquakes, impacts, or vibrations, mechanical anchors reach their ultimate load and fracture first, and the remaining load transfers instantly and entirely to the chemical anchors, causing instantaneous complete detachment

Under shear loads, because the threaded rod of chemical anchors and the sleeve of metal anchors differ in material - that is, their stiffness differs - it easily develops a tendency for the stiffer anchor to take the entire external force, resulting in an unsafe anchoring design.

2.3 Premises of Anchor Group Calculation Do Not Hold

The premise of anchor group calculation in JGJ 145-2013 is anchors of the same type, same size, and same load-bearing mechanism. Mixed arrangements without test reports are not allowed, and drawing review and third-party pull-out testing uniformly reject mixed-type schemes. The internal force calculation methods for anchor groups under tension and shear in the code are established on the assumption of same-type anchors; once different anchor types are mixed, the original calculation methods no longer apply.

III. Service Conditions Where Mixing Is Absolutely Prohibited

Service conditionMixing allowed?Reason
Load-bearing anchor group base plates (curtain walls, equipment foundations, steel structure column bases, cantilever brackets)Strictly prohibitedDifferent failure mechanisms, huge stiffness difference, severely reduced anchor group capacity
Cracked concrete, seismic-resistant membersStrictly prohibitedNeither ordinary expansion anchors nor ordinary chemical anchors can be used in such conditions
Inserts long-term exposed to moisture/underwaterStrictly prohibitedChemical anchor curing is affected, and mechanical anchors have limited corrosion protection
Load-bearing structures in seismic fortification zonesStrictly prohibitedundercut anchors or special reverse-cone chemical anchors must be used, and mixing is not allowed
Post-installed inserts requiring weldingConditionally allowedMechanical undercut anchors, or chemical anchors and mechanical anchors arranged alternately, with chemical anchors not exceeding half

IV. Design Considerations

4.1 Basic Principle: Same Type, Same Size

Designs should strictly comply with the requirements of Clause 4.3.6 of JGJ 145-2013, namely that anchor groups should use anchors of the same type and same size. This means:

  1. On the same base plate, mechanical anchors and chemical anchors must not be mixed

  2. On the same base plate, anchors of different sizes must not be mixed

  3. On the same base plate, anchors of different brands must not be mixed

4.2 Design Points for Welding Conditions

When adopting an alternating arrangement under welding conditions, note the following in design:

  1. Chemical anchors not exceeding half: for post-installed inserts in which chemical anchors exceed half, no welding may be performed on their components and connectors after positioning

  2. Welding temperature control: the chemical agents of chemical anchors are not heat resistant, and welding heat on post-installed inserts with chemical anchors directly affects their load-bearing capacity

  3. Welding sequence: welding should be completed first, followed by installation and curing of the chemical anchors

  4. Separate load capacity verification: the load capacity of the two anchor types should be verified separately, taking the sum of their respective capacities

4.3 Special Treatment in Load Capacity Calculation

When chemical anchors are mixed with expansion anchors, the selection principle is that the ultimate load capacity (characteristic value) of the chemical anchor equals that of the expansion anchor, which may require a larger diameter for the expansion anchor.

When chemical anchors and expansion anchors are mixed mainly under tension or bending, the calculation is essentially the same as using only one anchor type; for anchors mainly under shear, the sum of their respective load capacities is considered.

Note: the above calculation methods are theoretical discussions only; in actual projects, anchors of the same type should be used preferentially to avoid the calculation uncertainty and safety hazards introduced by mixing types.

4.4 Requirements for Design Documents

  • Specify the anchor type: design documents should clearly mark the anchor type (mechanical or chemical anchor) and size

  • Avoid vague wording: vague wording such as "post-installed anchor" or "chemical or mechanical bolt" must not appear

  • State the calculation basis: calculations of anchor group load capacity should state the code clauses and calculation methods used

  • Special service condition notes: if an alternating arrangement under welding conditions is adopted, it should be explained in the design documents with the proportion of chemical anchors noted

V. Precautions in Construction Practice

5.1 Strictly Follow the Drawings

During construction, anchors should be installed strictly according to the anchor types and sizes marked on the design drawings, and anchor types must not be changed without authorization. If unclear markings or mixed usage are found on site in the design drawings, the design institute should be consulted promptly for confirmation; do not decide on your own.

5.2 Material Acceptance on Delivery

  • Verify the anchor type: on delivery, verify that the anchor types and sizes match the design

  • Check product markings: check anchor product markings to avoid mixing different anchor types in storage

  • Store by category: anchors of different types and sizes should be stored by category with clear labels

5.3 On-Site Testing

According to JGJ 145-2013, on-site verification of anchor pull-out load capacity can use non-destructive and destructive testing. The non-destructive test load should reach 1.2 times the design value, held steady for no less than 2 minutes; an anchor is judged acceptable only if there is no slip, no loosening, and no cracking of the base material.

For mixed-type schemes, third-party testing agencies usually do not accept pull-out testing of mixed-type schemes, so mixed-type schemes are also not recommended from an acceptance standpoint.

VI. Daring Anchoring Solutions

6.1 Daring Mechanical Anchor Series

The Daring mechanical anchor series covers undercut, self-undercutting, drop-in, Anka, and heavy-duty mechanical anchors and other types, made of carbon steel/stainless steel with multi-coating processes; mechanical interlock delivers immediate locking upon installation with no curing required, with high load capacity, seismic resistance, and fatigue resistance; suitable for cracked/non-cracked concrete, natural stone, and other base materials, and widely used in curtain walls, steel structures, heavy equipment, rail transit, tunnel utility corridors, and various other anchoring scenarios.

6.2 Daring Chemical Anchor Series

The Daring chemical anchor series covers high-strength, capsule, special reverse-cone, and dynamic-load reverse-cone anchors and other types, paired with the DL-200E modified epoxy injection anchoring adhesive meeting the national Class A adhesive standard, with options of grade 5.8 or higher carbon steel or 304/316 stainless steel. The Daring high-strength chemical anchor comes with adhesive capsules that set quickly in 30 minutes (at room temperature), with M12 pull-out force up to 60kN.

6.3 Daring Full Product Lines

Daring offers full product lines of both mechanical anchors and chemical anchors, providing compliant single-type anchoring solutions for different service conditions, avoiding the design and acceptance risks of mixing anchor types. For anchor selection and design recommendations for a specific project, please consult the Daring technical team.

VII. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1Is it feasible to mix Daring mechanical anchors and chemical anchors?
In principle, it is not permitted at the code level. Clause 4.3.6 of JGJ 145-2013 explicitly requires that anchor groups use anchors of the same type and same size. Mixing causes the stiffer mechanical anchors to take the full load first, leaving chemical anchors nearly unloaded and severely reducing the anchor group capacity. Alternating arrangement of chemical anchors and mechanical anchors is allowed only under welding conditions, with chemical anchors not exceeding half.
Q2What are the risks of mixing mechanical anchors and chemical anchors?
The two anchor types differ fundamentally in failure mechanism and stiffness. Mechanical anchors are rigid and take load instantly, while the adhesive of chemical anchors provides elastic buffering. Under load, the stiffer mechanical anchors take the full tensile force first, chemical anchors are nearly unloaded, and the total capacity of the anchor group equals only that of the mechanical anchors alone. In an earthquake or vibration, mechanical anchors fracture first and the remaining load transfers instantly to the chemical anchors, causing complete detachment.
Q3Under what circumstances is alternating anchor arrangement allowed?
For post-installed inserts requiring welding after positioning, mechanical undercut anchors should be used, or chemical anchors and mechanical anchors should be arranged alternately. For post-installed inserts in which chemical anchors exceed half, no welding may be performed on their components and connectors after positioning. This exception applies only to welding conditions.
Q4Under which service conditions must anchor types never be mixed?
Mixing is strictly prohibited for load-bearing anchor group base plates (curtain walls, equipment foundations, steel structure column bases, cantilever brackets); for cracked concrete and seismic-resistant members; for inserts long-term submerged in damp/underwater conditions; and for load-bearing structures in seismic fortification zones.
Q5What anchor products does Daring offer?
Daring offers full product lines of both mechanical anchors and chemical anchors. The Daring mechanical anchor series covers undercut, self-undercutting, drop-in, Anka, and heavy-duty mechanical anchors, among other types. The Daring chemical anchor series covers high-strength, capsule, special reverse-cone, and dynamic-load reverse-cone anchors, among other types, paired with the DL-200E modified epoxy injection anchoring adhesive.

Daring offers full product lines of both mechanical anchors and chemical anchors, covering mechanical anchors (undercut, self-undercutting, drop-in, Anka, and heavy-duty) and chemical anchors (high-strength, capsule, special reverse-cone, and dynamic-load reverse-cone), among other types, and can provide compliant single-type anchoring solutions for different service conditions, avoiding the design and acceptance risks of mixing anchor types. For anchor selection and design recommendations for a specific project, please consult the Daring technical team.

References

JGJ 145-2013, Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures - Clause 4.3.6: anchor groups should use anchors of the same type and same size

GB 50367-2013, Design Code for Strengthening Concrete Structures - anchor selection provisions for load-bearing structures

Shanghai Technical Specification for Building Curtain Wall Engineering - provisions on alternating anchor arrangement under welding conditions

Daring website - Undercut Mechanical Anchor product page

Daring website - Chemical Anchor Product Series

Daring website - DL-200E Injection Anchoring Adhesive product page

Back to Daring Home  Back to Top