The conclusion up front:as for the shear and tension of chemical anchors,there is no absolute "which one matters more"; the two are mutually constraining indicators that must be checked simultaneously, and what matters is theloading condition. From the failure mechanism, however, tension is usually the more criticalcontrolling condition: in tension failure, the load capacity relies mainly on the concrete cone strength, with large scatter; in shear failure, the steel shear strength is about0.58 times the tensile strength (for stainless steel anchors), and the failure is more ductile. Under combined tension and shear, the code requires verification withan interaction equation with an exponent of 1.5 or 2.0 for verification; the capacity in either direction alone cannot satisfy the check, and the two must be verified jointly. The core of the selection logic comes down to three points:tension-dominated conditions (cantilever structures, equipment lifting): look first at embedment depth and concrete cone load capacity;shear-dominated conditions (shear wall connections, curtain wall transoms): look first at anchor diameter and steel shear strength;combined tension-shear conditions (seismic bracing, dynamic-load equipment): verification with the interaction equation is mandatory, together with the capacity reduction factor under seismic action. In addition, in structural member connections in seismic fortification zones,ordinary chemical anchors are strictly prohibited as connections under tension, edge shear, or combined tension and shear; special reverse-cone chemical anchors or undercut anchors must be used instead.
In chemical anchor selection, the question designers wrestle with most often is "for tension and shear, which one should govern?" In many project failures, the cause is not insufficient capacity in a single direction but a failure to properly assess the mutual weakening under combined tension and shear. This article systematically explains the relationship between the tension and shear capacity of chemical anchors and the selection methods for different loading conditions, from three perspectives: code formulas, loading conditions and selection logic.
1. Differences in the capacity calculation logic between tension and shear
1.1 Tension capacity — multi-level verification
According to Clause 6.2.1 of JGJ 145-2013, Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures, the tension capacity of a chemical anchor must simultaneously satisfy the following four checks:
Nsd ≤ NRd,s(steel failure)
Nsd ≤ NRd,p(mixed failure)
Nsd ≤ NRd,c(concrete cone failure)
Nsd ≤ NRd,sp(concrete splitting failure)
where Nsd is the design tensile force of the anchor; NRd,s is the design tension capacity for steel failure of the anchor; NRd,p is the design tension capacity for mixed failure; NRd,c is the design tension capacity for concrete cone failure; NRd,sp is the design tension capacity for concrete splitting failure. The tension check must control all four failure modes simultaneously; if any one check is not met, the connection is judged non-compliant.
This means that under tension the factors affecting load capacity are far more complex than expected: besides the steel strength of the anchor itself, parameters such as the concrete strength class, embedment depth, edge distance, spacing and base material thickness all directly determine the tension capacity. When the embedment depth is insufficient, no matter how high the steel strength of the anchor, premature failure occurs because the concrete cone load capacity is inadequate.
1.2 Shear capacity — dual control by steel and concrete
The shear capacity must be checked separately for steel shear failure and concrete edge failure:
VRd,s = k · VRk,s / γRs,V(steel shear failure)
VRd,c = k · VRk,c / γRc,V(concrete edge failure)
where k is the reduction factor for anchoring capacity under seismic action; VRk,s is the characteristic shear capacity for steel failure; VRk,c is the characteristic shear capacity for concrete edge failure; γRs,V is the partial factor for the shear capacity in steel failure; γRc,V is the partial factor for the shear capacity in concrete edge failure, taken as 1.5.
Unlike tension, the shear capacity on the steel failure path is directly determined by the cross-sectional area of the anchor and the shear strength of the material. According to the code, the design shear strength of a stainless steel anchor may be taken as0.58 times its design tensile strength. Therefore, once the steel strength grade of the anchor is fixed, the upper limit of its shear capacity can be calculated directly.
However, the shear check cannot look at steel alone. When an anchor is close to the edge of a concrete member, concrete edge wedge failure may occur before steel failure. The smaller the edge distance, the lower the concrete edge shear capacity — this is the failure path most easily overlooked in shear-dominated conditions.
1.3 Key parameter comparison — the different embedment depth requirements for tension and shear
The degree to which embedment depth affects tension and shear capacity differs significantly. According to the code, when capsule chemical anchors are used, for anchors bearing tension the effective embedment depth must not be less than8.0 times the nominal diameter of the anchor; for anchors bearing shear, the effective embedment depth must not be less than6.5 times the nominal diameter of the anchor. Tension imposes the stricter embedment depth requirement, because tension capacity depends directly on the effective projected area of the concrete cone, and embedment depth is the core parameter determining that area.
2. Combined tension and shear — the critical decision point in selection
2.1 Why combined tension and shear is more dangerous than a single action
When an anchor bears tension and shear simultaneously, the capacities in the two directionsare not simply added together; they weaken each other. Once the concrete has been weakened by cone failure in the tension direction, the edge capacity in the shear direction drops accordingly, and vice versa. This is the interaction effect of "combined tension and shear".
According to Clause 6.1.29 of JGJ 145-2013, under elastic design the concrete failure capacity under combined tension and shear shall be verified with the following formulas:
(Nsd / NRd,c)1.5 + (Vsd / VRd,c)1.5 ≤ 1
When steel failure governs, the exponent of the interaction equation is taken as2.0:
(Nsd / NRd,s)2.0 + (Vsd / VRd,s)2.0 ≤ 1
where Nsd is the design tensile force of the anchor; NRd,s is the design tension capacity for steel failure of the anchor; Vsd is the design shear force of the anchor; VRd,s is the design shear capacity for steel failure of the anchor. For anchor groups, the calculation shall use, respectively, the design tensile force of the most tensioned anchor and the design shear force of the most heavily sheared anchor in the group.
2.2 The relationship between the tension-shear ratio and load capacity
Test research shows that the capacity of a chemical anchor under combined tension and sheardecreases as the tension-shear ratio increases. This means that the higher the proportion of tension in the combined action, the lower the anchor's overall capacity. When the design tensile force Vsd ≤ 0.2VRd, the full tension strength is effective; when the design shear force Nsd ≤ 0.2NRd, the full shear strength is effective; when both exceed 20%, verification with the interaction equation is mandatory.
The direct guidance of this rule for selection is: in combined tension-shear conditions,embedment depth should be increased first to raise the tension capacity, because insufficient tension capacity is often the controlling factor in combined-action failure. Meanwhile, appropriately increasing the anchor diameter raises both the tension and shear capacity, but it must be checked whether the edge distance and spacing requirements are still met.
3. Selection logic for different loading conditions
3.1 Tension-dominated conditions
Typical scenarios: cantilever structural members, equipment lifting anchorage, top fixing points of curtain walls, and post-installed beam-column joints.
Load characteristics: the anchor bears mainly axial tension with a small shear share (usually <20%); the governing failure modes are concrete cone failure or tensile rupture of the anchor steel. Cantilever structural members must also account for the influence factor of the structural stress state on load capacity; for cantilever structural members, this factor should be taken as 1.5.
Selection points:
Embedment depth first: tension capacity is governed by the concrete cone strength, and embedment depth is the decisive parameter. The effective embedment depth should not be less than 8.0 times the nominal diameter of the anchor.
Edge distance and spacing checks: tension conditions are more sensitive to edge distance than shear conditions. The critical edge distance for concrete cone failure is usually taken as 1.5 times the effective embedment depth.
Concrete strength class: the strength class of the base concrete should not be lower than C25 and must not exceed C60. Where the structural safety class is Class I, the strength of the base concrete should not be lower than C30.
Selection direction: larger-diameter anchors are not necessarily the optimal solution. When embedment depth is limited, appropriately increasing the number of anchors is more effective than increasing the diameter.
3.2 Shear-dominated conditions
Typical scenarios: shear wall-to-steel beam connections, curtain wall transom-to-mullion connections, and the root fixing of pipe supports and hangers.
Load characteristics: the anchor bears mainly shear perpendicular to its axis with a small tension share (usually <20%); the governing failure modes are steel shear failure of the anchor or concrete edge wedge failure. Selection for these conditions is relatively simple, because the steel shear capacity can be calculated directly from the cross-sectional area and the material strength.
Selection points:
Steel shear strength is the upper limit: the shear strength of a stainless steel anchor is about 0.58 times its design tensile strength. Once the anchor diameter is fixed, the steel shear capacity is a fixed value.
Edge distance governs concrete failure: under shear, concrete edge wedge failure is the main risk. The smaller the edge distance, the lower the concrete edge shear capacity. When an anchor is close to an edge, the edge distance should be increased or a base material with reinforcement should be used.
The embedment depth requirement is relatively lenient: for anchors bearing shear, the effective embedment depth should not be less than 6.5 times the nominal diameter, lower than the 8.0-times requirement for tension.
Shear distribution in anchor groups: when an anchor group is under shear, the shear force is distributed unevenly among the anchors, and the internal forces of the group under shear must be calculated in accordance with the code.
3.3 Combined tension and shear conditions
Typical scenarios: seismic bracing anchorage, fixing of dynamic equipment bases, root connections of connecting corridors, and inter-story curtain wall connections.
Load characteristics: neither tension nor shear can be neglected; if either direction accounts for more than 20%, verification with the interaction equation is mandatory. Among chemical anchor selection tasks, these conditions arethe most complex and the most error-prone scenarios. Taking the root connection of a connecting corridor as an example, the bending moments produced by vertical loads and wind put the upper anchors in tension and the lower anchors in compression, while horizontal seismic action produces shear, so the anchors are in a typical state of combined tension and shear.
Selection points:
Verification with the interaction equation is mandatory: use the interaction equation with an exponent of 1.5 (concrete failure governing) or 2.0 (steel failure governing); the tension and shear must not simply be checked separately and then added.
Tension capacity is usually the bottleneck: tension capacity decreases as the tension-shear ratio increases, and under combined loading it is often the direction that fails first. In selection, take an appropriately "larger instead of smaller" approach — use anchors with a larger diameter or deeper embedment so that NRd,c retains an adequate margin.
Restrictions in seismic fortification zones: in seismic fortification zones, ordinary chemical anchors should not be used as connections under tension, edge shear, or combined tension and shear. Special reverse-cone chemical anchors or undercut mechanical anchors must be used instead.
Failure mode control: for anchorage connections of structural members under tension, edge shear, or combined tension and shear, and of non-structural members in lifeline projects, the failure mode should be controlled as steel failure of the anchor or post-installed rebar, not concrete failure.
3.4 Special requirements for seismic fortification zones
Seismic fortification zones impose the strictest restrictions on chemical anchor selection. According to Table 4.3.9 of JGJ 145-2013, the reduction factor k for anchoring capacity under seismic action varies with anchor type and failure mode:
| Failure mode and anchor type | Tension (k) | Shear (k) |
|---|---|---|
| Steel failure of anchor or post-installed rebar | 1.0 | 1.0 |
| Special reverse-cone chemical anchor (concrete failure) | 0.8 | 0.7 |
| Ordinary chemical anchor (concrete failure) | 0.7 | 0.6 |
| Ordinary chemical anchor (mixed failure) | 0.7 | — |
It can be seen that under seismic action the capacity reduction for ordinary chemical anchors is greater than for special reverse-cone chemical anchors. The shear capacity reduction factor for ordinary chemical anchors is 0.6, versus 0.7 for special reverse-cone chemical anchors. This is why the code requires that, in structural member connections in seismic fortification zones, ordinary chemical anchors are strictly prohibited as connections under tension, edge shear, or combined tension and shear, and special reverse-cone chemical anchors or undercut anchors must be used instead.
In addition, in seismic design, anchors should preferably be placed in the compression zone and non-cracked zones of the concrete structure, and should not be placed in plain concrete zones or tension zones with a crack width Wmax ≥ 0.3mm.
4. Summary of the selection decision process
| Loading condition | Governing direction | Selection priority | Recommended anchor type |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cantilever structures / equipment lifting | Tension-governed | Embedment depth > diameter > edge distance | Special reverse-cone chemical anchor |
| Shear walls / curtain wall transoms | Shear-governed | Diameter > edge distance > embedment depth | High-strength chemical anchor |
| Seismic bracing / dynamic-load equipment | Combined tension and shear governed | Interaction equation verification > embedment depth > diameter | Special reverse-cone chemical anchor or undercut anchor |
| Pipe supports and hangers | Shear-dominated / combined tension and shear | Verify with the interaction equation | Special reverse-cone chemical anchor |
5. Daring chemical anchor product fit and selection support
The Daring chemical anchor series covers high-strength chemical anchors, special reverse-cone chemical anchors and other categories, paired with Daring's DL-200E modified epoxy injection anchoring adhesive meeting the national Grade A adhesive standard. Taking an M12, Grade 8.8 chemical anchor as an example, the ultimate pull-out force of Daring's product can exceed 60kN, with failure by tensile rupture of the anchor — essentially no difference in behavior from imported products of the same grade. According to GB/T 3098.1-2010, the minimum tensile load of an M12 Grade 8.8 chemical anchor is 67.4kN, a value determined by the nominal stress cross-sectional area of the threaded rod and the steel strength grade; whether Daring or an imported brand, as long as the material grade is the same, the theoretical load capacity is exactly the same.
Daring's DL-200E modified epoxy injection anchoring adhesive offers anti-dispersion performance underwater and wet-surface bonding capability, with strong bonding anchoring force as well as temperature and seismic resistance, and it is suitable for cracked concrete. Daring's special reverse-cone chemical anchors are suitable for load-bearing structural connections in seismic fortification zones and can provide the technical parameters required for capacity calculations in accordance with JGJ 145-2013. Daring also provides technical support for verifying combined tension-shear loading, helping designers determine the optimal selection for specific conditions.
For technical guidance on tension and shear selection calculations and scheme design for chemical anchors on a specific project, please contact the Daring technical team.
6. Frequently asked questions
| Q1 | Which matters more for chemical anchors: tension or shear capacity? There is no absolute answer; it depends on the loading condition. Under tension, tension capacity is the controlling indicator; under shear, shear capacity is the controlling indicator; under combined tension and shear, both must be verified jointly. From the failure mechanism, however, tension failure shows greater scatter, and tension capacity decreases as the tension-shear ratio increases, so under combined loading it is often the controlling direction. |
| Q2 | What is the interaction equation for combined tension and shear? According to Clause 6.1.29 of JGJ 145-2013, for concrete failure the verification uses an exponent of 1.5: (Nsd/NRd,c)1.5+(Vsd/VRd,c)1.5≤1; for steel failure it uses an exponent of 2.0: (Nsd/NRd,s)2.0+(Vsd/VRd,s)2.0≤1. |
| Q3 | Why does tension demand a greater embedment depth than shear? Tension capacity depends directly on the effective projected area of the concrete cone, and embedment depth is the core parameter determining that area. The code requires that the effective embedment depth of an anchor bearing tension be no less than 8.0 times its nominal diameter, and no less than 6.5 times its nominal diameter for an anchor bearing shear. |
| Q4 | How is the capacity of chemical anchors reduced under seismic action? According to Table 4.3.9 of JGJ 145-2013, under seismic action the tension capacity reduction factor for ordinary chemical anchors is 0.7 and the shear factor is 0.6; for special reverse-cone chemical anchors the tension factor is 0.8 and the shear factor is 0.7. Ordinary chemical anchors are reduced more than special reverse-cone chemical anchors. |
| Q5 | Can ordinary chemical anchors be used in seismic fortification zones? Not for load-bearing structural connections. In seismic fortification zones, ordinary chemical anchors should not be used as connections under tension, edge shear, or combined tension and shear; special reverse-cone chemical anchors or undercut anchors must be used instead. In seismic design, anchors should preferably be placed in the compression zone and non-cracked zones of the concrete structure. |
| Q6 | What are the special requirements for anchor selection in cantilever structures? Cantilever structural members must account for the influence factor of the structural stress state on load capacity, which should be taken as 1.5, meaning the capacity needs an additional 50% safety margin. Embedment depth should be increased as a priority, and edge distance and spacing must be carefully checked. Anchorage connections of structural members under tension, edge shear, or combined tension and shear should be controlled to steel failure of the anchor. |
The Daring chemical anchor series covers high-strength, capsule, special reverse-cone and dynamic-load reverse-cone anchors, paired with Daring's DL-200E modified epoxy injection anchoring adhesive meeting the national Grade A adhesive standard. The DL-200E offers a degree of moisture tolerance and can be used for underwater rebar installation, but hole cleaning must be strictly carried out during construction. For technical guidance on tension and shear selection calculations and scheme design for chemical anchors on a specific project, please contact the Daring technical team.
References
JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures — tension and shear capacity calculation of chemical anchors and verification of combined tension-shear loading
GB 50367-2013 Code for Design of Strengthening of Concrete Structures — basic provisions for anchorage design
GB/T 3098.1-2010 Mechanical Properties of Fasteners — Bolts, Screws and Studs — minimum tensile load provisions
Daring website — M12 chemical anchor specifications and pull-out force explained
