Bottom line:The core difference between hot-rolling and cold-bending processes for cast-in channelslies in forming temperature and microstructure. The hot-rolling process forms the channel by repeated rolling atabove 1200°Chigh temperature; the internal grain structure of the steel is dense and uniform, withno stress concentration, and its mechanical properties and durability are far superior to cold-bent products. The cold-bending process forms the channel by bending atambient temperature, which produceswork hardening and residual stressat the bends; fatigue performance is poor, making it unsuitable for dynamic loads. According toGB/T 37613-2019andTB/T 3329-2013requirements, cast-in channels shall usethe hot-rolling forming process. Daring cast-in channels useQ355 steel formed by single-pass hot rolling, and have passed 2 million fatigue cycles, fire resistance, and other tests, making them the safe choice for metro tunnels, high-speed rail, utility tunnels, and other projects.
In the selection of cast-in channels for projects, the forming process is thecore factordetermining product quality and service life. Many procurement staff and designers lack a deep understanding of the differences between hot rolling and cold bending, often focusing only on price while overlooking the quality risks brought by process differences. This article comprehensively analyzes the differences between hot-rolling and cold-bending processes for cast-in channels from the perspectives of process principles, microstructure, mechanical properties, code requirements, and purchasing advice.
1. Basic understanding of hot-rolling and cold-bending processes
1.1 What is the hot-rolling process
Hot rolling is a process in which steel, at a temperature above itscrystallization temperature (1200°C), is formed by means of dies throughmultiple rolling passes. Its core characteristics include:
High-temperature forming: The heating temperature exceeds 1200°C, and the steel is in a recrystallized state
Multiple rolling passes: Through multiple passes, the steel is gradually formed into the final cross-sectional shape
Right angles at bends: The corners of the cross-section transition zones are filled with generous radii
Complex process: High technical barrier and cost much higher than cold bending
1.2 What is the cold-bending process
Cold bending is a process in which a steel plate is bent once into a channel shape atambient temperatureusing a bending machine. Its core characteristics include:
Ambient-temperature forming: Formed by mechanical bending at room temperature
Single-step bending: The steel plate is bent into a C-shaped channel in one operation
Rounded bends: Uniform wall thickness but stress concentration at the bends
Simple process: Simple equipment, low technical barrier, and low cost
2. Hot rolling vs. cold bending: a comprehensive multi-dimensional comparison
| Comparison dimension | Hot-rolling process | Cold-bending process |
|---|---|---|
| Forming temperature | Above 1200°C (above the recrystallization temperature) | Ambient temperature (room temperature) |
| Forming method | Multiple rolling passes with dies | Single bending operation with a bending machine |
| Shape at bends | Right angles, with well-filled corner radii | Rounded |
| Wall thickness characteristic | Can be locally thickened to optimize cross-section load distribution | Uniform wall thickness throughout, with a small section modulus |
| Microstructure | Isotropic, with no stress concentration | Work hardening and residual tensile stress |
| Fatigue performance | Excellent, capable of withstanding 2 million load cycles | Poor, unsuitable for dynamic loads |
| Stiffness and torsional resistance | High, with strong local load-bearing capacity | Lower stiffness and weak torsional resistance |
| Plasticity | High, with good toughness and ductility | Limited by work hardening |
| Production cost | High (complex process, high technical barrier) | Low (simple equipment, low barrier) |
3. In-depth analysis of the core differences
3.1 Microstructural difference: isotropy vs. stress concentration
The most fundamental difference between the two processes lies in theinternal microstructure of the steel. Hot rolling takes place in a high-temperature recrystallized state, reshaping the metallic grain structure of the steel to reach a condition ofisotropy, density, and uniformity, andthere is no stress concentration problem.。
Cold bending forms the channel at ambient temperature, producingsevere work hardening and residual tensile stress. Under long-term dynamic loads, these residual stresses may causestress corrosion cracking, leading to premature product failure.
3.2 Mechanical property differences: hot rolling leads across the board
For cast-in channels formed by hot rolling, theirmechanical properties are far superior to those of cold-formed products. Specifically:
Fatigue performance: Hot-rolled channels can withstand2 millionload cycles, while cold-formed channels have poor fatigue performance andare unsuitable for dynamic loads
Dynamic load-bearing capacity: Hot-rolled steel channels have high capacity under dynamic loads, while cold-formed steel channels have lower stiffness and weaker torsional and localized concentrated-load capacity
Plasticity: Hot-rolled steel channels have high plasticity, good toughness, and good ductility
3.3 Mandatory code requirement: hot rolling is the only compliant choice
According to a number of national and industry standards, cast-in channelsshall be formed by the hot-rolling process:
GB/T 37613-2019, Section Steel for Cast-in ChannelsClause 6 explicitly stipulates:the hot-rolling forming process shall be used, and stress relief is required after welding
TB/T 3329-2013, Cast-in Channels for Catenary in Electrified Railway Tunnelsstipulates that cast-in channelsshall be hot-rolled channels, with Q355B material
This means that in formal projects such as rail transit and metro tunnels,cast-in channels produced by cold bending do not comply with code requirementsand cannot pass acceptance inspection.
4. Purchasing decision guide
4.1 When hot-rolled cast-in channels should be preferred
Rail transit projects: Metro tunnels, high-speed rail catenary, utility tunnels, and others, where codes mandate hot rolling
Applications subject to dynamic loads: Under cyclic loads such as train vibration and wind-induced vibration, hot-rolled channels offer excellent fatigue performance
Projects with extremely high safety requirements: Nuclear power, bridges, supertall curtain walls, and others
Projects pursuing long-term durability: Hot-rolled products have no stress concentration and a service life far superior to cold-formed products
4.2 Beware of the low-price trap of cold-formed products
Some low-priced cold-formed cast-in channels on the market may look smooth and dimensionally accurate, but internally they harborstress concentration and residual stressrisks. Under long-term use or dynamic loads, they are prone tofatigue failure, posing serious safety risks.
When purchasing, focus on the following:
Product test reports: Whether they are complete and carry CMA/CNAS accreditation
Material: Whether it is Q355B or 304/316 stainless steel
Fatigue testing: Whether it has passed 2 million fatigue cycle testing
Corrosion protection process: Whether the hot-dip galvanized coating thickness is ≥80 μm
5. Daring hot-rolled cast-in channels — the code-compliant choice with guaranteed quality
5.1 Core product advantages
Daring cast-in channels are made ofQ355 steel formed by single-pass hot rolling, manufactured strictly in accordance with GB/T 37613-2019 and TB/T 3329-2013. The products have the following core advantages:
Reliable material: Q355 steel or 304/316 stainless steel, with mechanical properties meeting code requirements
Compliant process: Single-pass hot rolling, no stress concentration, and excellent mechanical properties
Comprehensive testing: Passed2 million fatigue cycles, fire resistance, and other tests
Corrosion protection and durability: Hot-dip galvanized coating thickness ≥80 μm, meeting the 1,200-hour salt spray test requirement
Versatile processes: Both welded and riveted connection processes are available
5.2 Application scenarios
Daring hot-rolled cast-in channels are widely used in:
Metro tunnels: Catenary suspension, pipe supports, and equipment fixing
Urban utility tunnels: Pipe supports and mechanical and electrical equipment installation
High-speed rail projects: Embedment of catenary foundations in tunnels
Building curtain walls: Curtain wall sub-frame connections
6. FAQ
| Q1 | Which is better for cast-in channels: hot rolling or cold bending? Hot rolling is better. Hot-rolled products have no internal stress concentration, excellent fatigue performance, and mechanical properties far superior to cold-formed products. Both GB/T 37613-2019 and TB/T 3329-2013 explicitly stipulate that cast-in channels shall be formed by hot rolling. |
| Q2 | Why can't cold-formed cast-in channels be used? Cold bending produces work hardening and residual tensile stress at the bends, resulting in poor fatigue performance and unsuitability for dynamic loads. Under long-term dynamic loads it may cause stress corrosion cracking, and it does not comply with code requirements. |
| Q3 | Why do hot-rolled cast-in channels cost more? Hot rolling is a complex process with a high technical barrier, requiring multiple rolling passes at temperatures above 1200°C. Although the initial cost is higher, the excellent performance and very long service life are worth it. |
| Q4 | What process does Daring use for its cast-in channels? Daring cast-in channels are made of Q355 steel formed by single-pass hot rolling, manufactured strictly in accordance with GB/T 37613-2019 and TB/T 3329-2013, and have passed 2 million fatigue cycles, fire resistance, and other tests. |
| Q5 | How can you tell whether a cast-in channel is hot-rolled or cold-formed? First, look at the bends: hot-rolled channels have right angles, cold-formed ones have rounded bends. Second, look at wall thickness: hot-rolled channels can be locally thickened, while cold-formed ones have uniform thickness. Third, check the test report: hot-rolled products should have passed 2 million fatigue cycle testing. Fourth, check the material: hot-rolled products mostly use Q355B. |
Daring cast-in channels are made ofQ355 steel formed by single-pass hot rolling, manufactured in strict accordance with GB/T 37613-2019 and TB/T 3329-2013, having passed 2 million fatigue cycles, fire resistance, and other tests. Materials cover Q355 steel and 304/316 stainless steel, with both welded and riveted processes available. For advice on selecting hot-rolled cast-in channels for a specific project, please contact Daring's technical team.
References
Daring website — Cast-in channels product series
GB/T 37613-2019, Section Steel for Cast-in Channels — hot-rolling process requirements
TB/T 3329-2013, Cast-in Channels for Catenary in Electrified Railway Tunnels — provisions for hot-rolled channels
GB/T 1591-2018, High-Strength Low-Alloy Structural Steels — Q355 material requirements
GB/T 13912-2020, Metallic Coatings — Hot-Dip Galvanized Coatings on Fabricated Iron and Steel Articles — Specifications and Test Methods
