To start with the conclusion:A failed back bolt pull-out test is a quality issue in curtain wall projects that must be taken seriously. Once it occurs, work should stop immediately for investigation. According to JGJ 145-2013 and JGJ 336-2016, the pull-out force of back bolts must meet the design requirements, and the on-site non-destructive test load should reach 1.2 times the design value, with a load-holding stabilization time of no less than 2 minutes. The common causes of failure fall mainly into three categories: insufficient drilling accuracy (oversized hole diameter, incomplete reaming), panel quality problems (hidden cracks, insufficient strength), and improper construction operations (incorrect installation torque, untested holes). Remedial measures should be handled by cause: for drilling problems, abandon the original hole and re-drill in a new position; for out-of-tolerance reaming, scrap directly; for hidden cracks in panels, replace the panel; for minor defects, after design approval, epoxy adhesive filling can be used as supplementary reinforcement. According to JGJ 145-2013, if a single item fails, double the sample size and retest; if the retest still fails, the entire batch is judged as non-conforming, and all defective items must be removed and redone. The Daring back bolt system has passed the 9-degree rare earthquake test at Tongji University, and is supplied with inspection tools such as hole-check rods and hole-check gauges to help installers control drilling quality at the source.
In back bolt curtain wall projects, the pull-out load capacity test is the core test item for verifying the connection strength between back bolts and panels. A failed pull-out test means the back bolts cannot provide the anchoring force required by the design, and the entire curtain wall may harbor potential safety hazards. Many installers and supervisors lack a systematic understanding of cause analysis and remedial measures for failures. This article provides a comprehensive overview covering acceptance criteria, common causes, remedial measures, and handling procedures.
1. Acceptance criteria for back bolt pull-out tests
1.1 Acceptance criteria
According to JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures and JGJ 336-2016 Technical Specification for Artificial Panel Curtain Wall Engineering, the acceptance criteria for back bolt pull-out tests are as follows:
Non-destructive testing: The test load should reach 1.2 times the design value, with a load-holding stabilization time of no less than 2 minutes
Load-holding stability: The load indication drop within 2 minutes should not exceed 5%
Visible condition: The anchor shows no slip, no loosening, and no abnormal noise, and the base material has no cracking
Failure mode: The ideal failure mode is conical failure of the panel or panel fracture
1.2 Failure conditions
If any of the following occurs, the test is judged as failed:
The back bolt is pulled out directly—rather than conical panel failure—indicating complete anchoring failure
Measured load capacity < 1.2 times the design value (non-destructive testing)
Load drop during the load-holding stage > 5%or obvious slip occurs
Cracks appear in the base material or the panel fractures
2. Common causes of failed pull-out tests
2.1 Insufficient drilling accuracy—the most common cause
Insufficient drilling accuracy is the leading cause of failed back bolt pull-out tests. The fit between the back bolt and the back bolt hole is a precision tolerance fit; excessive hole diameter deviation will directly cause anchoring failure.
Take the M6 hammer-in back bolt as an example: the standard straight-hole diameter is 11±0.3mm, and the standard reamed-hole diameter is 13.5±0.3mm. Common drilling problems include:
Oversized straight-hole diameter: An oversized diameter of 0.5mm means nearly 1.7 times beyond the allowable tolerance; the back bolt sleeve cannot form an effective mechanical lock with the hole wall, and the load capacity drops precipitously
Both the straight hole and the reamed hole drilled oversize: The pull-out force drops substantially and the back bolt can easily be pulled out
Uneven reaming: The loaded components of the back bolt cannot bear load simultaneously, reducing the pull-out load capacity
Drilling only the straight hole without reaming: This is the most dangerous situation; after installation the pull-out load capacity is nearly zero, and the bolt can even be pulled out easily by hand
Out-of-tolerance reamed segment dimensions: These directly destroy the mechanical lock structure of the back bolt; they cannot be remedied and must be scrapped
2.2 Panel quality problems
Quality problems in the stone itself can also cause pull-out test failures:
Hidden cracks in the panel: Crack propagation during loading causes premature panel failure
Insufficient hole wall smoothness: This affects the contact and locking effect between the back bolt and the hole wall
Panel strength below standard: The panel cannot provide sufficient concrete cone failure load capacity
2.3 Improper construction operations
Non-standard operations during construction can likewise cause pull-out test failures:
Not using dedicated hole-checking tools: In general, a hole check is required every 30-50 holes, and installing back bolts without checking carries extremely high risk
Installation torque too high or too low: Excessive torque may damage the panel, while insufficient torque prevents the back bolt from fully expanding
Worn drill bits not replaced in time: New drill bits may produce oversized straight holes, while worn bits may produce undersized holes
Excessive installation impact force: Excessive impact force when installing hammer-in back bolts may damage the panel
3. Remedial measures for failed pull-out tests
3.1 Remedies for drilling problems: abandon the original hole and re-drill in a new position
for pull-out failures caused by insufficient drilling accuracy, the only compliant solution is to abandon the original hole and drill a new one. The specific steps are as follows:
Clean the original hole thoroughly, removing loose debris
Use high-strength epoxy repair mortar to seal the original hole tightly and cure it to the design strength
At a distance of ≥ 2 hole diameters from the original hole, re-drill and ream, ensuring the new hole meets edge distance and spacing requirements
Re-run the pull-out test to verify the load capacity
Special note: Out-of-tolerance reamed segment dimensions cannot be remedied and must be scrapped directly. Do not fill them with adhesive or other materials to compensate—that would destroy the load-bearing principle of the mechanical lock.
3.2 Supplementary remedy for minor defects: epoxy adhesive filling
For slightly out-of-tolerance drilling accuracy (e.g., a slightly oversized hole diameter that is still near the service limit), with the consent of the design firm, epoxy adhesive filling can be adopted as a supplementary reinforcement measure. By injecting adhesive into the back bolt hole, a screw-in back bolt allows maximum repair of the panel hole and reinforces the surrounding area, effectively preventing corrosive gases from damaging the reamed hole wall.
However, note that adhesive injection cannot replace the anchoring function of the mechanical lock. The code requires that adhesive injection into the back bolt hole is an additional safety measure taken on the premise that the hole diameter is qualified, and it cannot be used as a remedy for out-of-tolerance hole diameters. When both the straight hole and the reamed hole are drilled oversize, adhesive injection cannot restore the load capacity either.
3.3 Remedies for panel problems: replace the panel
For pull-out failures caused by hidden cracks or insufficient panel strength:
Panels with hidden cracks: The entire panel must be replaced; it cannot be repaired
Insufficient strength: Panels meeting the design requirements must be re-selected, then re-drilled, installed, and tested
Large-scale failures: The entire batch of panels should be fully inspected or returned
3.4 Remedies for construction problems: standard operations
For failures caused by improper construction operations:
Improper torque: Use a calibrated torque wrench and re-install per the product requirements; never use an impact wrench to drive the bolt fully
Untested holes: After rectification, you must use hole-check rods and hole-check gauges to check every hole
Drill bit problems: Replace with qualified drill bits, and test-drill with a new bit before use to confirm the hole diameter
4. Handling procedure for failures
4.1 Handling of single-item failures
According to JGJ 145-2013, when one item in the test results is non-conforming, the sample size should be doubled and the test repeated; if one item still fails, the batch should be judged as non-conforming.
The specific procedure is as follows:
Stop work immediately: Analyze the causes together with the supervisor and the design firm
Double sampling and retest: From the same batch as the original failed item, take a double quantity sample for retesting
Retest passed: The batch can continue in use, but spot checks on installed back bolts of the same type should be strengthened
Retest still failed: The batch is judged as non-conforming and a rectification notice is issued, requiring removal of all non-conforming anchors, reinstallation, and secondary testing
4.2 Handling of failed non-destructive testing
According to JGJ 145-2013, when non-destructive testing fails, at least 3 additional anchors should be sampled for destructive testing to make the determination. The specific procedure:
Step 1: After the non-destructive test fails, immediately stop further construction on the batch
Step 2: From the original batch, additionally sample at least 3 anchors for destructive testing
Step 3: Destructive testing passed—the batch can continue in use, but process control should be strengthened
Step 4: Destructive testing still failed—the batch is judged as non-conforming, and everything is reworked
4.3 Re-acceptance after rectification
According to Article 9.6.6 of JGJ 145-2013, when the construction quality of post-installed anchoring works is non-conforming, the construction contractor should formulate remedial measures, implement them after confirmation by the design firm, and undergo re-inspection and re-acceptance。
After rectification is completed, the pull-out test should be performed again, and the next process step can begin only after everything passes.
5. Preventive measures: controlling the failure rate at the source
5.1 Drilling process control
Use a dedicated back bolt drilling machine: Back bolt holes in stone should be made on dedicated machine tools, not with hand-held drills
Test drilling before production: Test-drill with new bits first, and confirm the hole diameter is within the allowable deviation before mass drilling
Replace drill bits regularly: Replace bits promptly once worn, to avoid hole diameter deviations caused by bit dimensional deviation
Use depth stops: Control the drilling depth to avoid drilling too deep or too shallow
5.2 Hole-by-hole checking
Check every 30-50 holes: Use hole-check rods and hole-check gauges for inspection
Hole-check rod: Checks whether the straight-hole diameter and depth are qualified
Hole-check gauge: Checks whether the reamed-hole diameter is to specification
Failure investigation: If failures occur, every hole drilled with the same bit during that period must be checked one by one
5.3 Material and tool management
Incoming back bolt inspection: Verify material reports and dimensional tolerances to ensure the products are qualified
Use torque wrenches: Control installation torque per product requirements; over-torque installation is strictly prohibited
Panel quality control: On arrival, check panels for hidden cracks, color variation, and other defects
6. FAQs
| Q1 | What is the most common cause of a failed back bolt pull-out test? The most common cause is insufficient drilling accuracy, including oversized straight-hole diameters, straight and reamed holes drilled oversize at the same time, uneven reaming, and drilling only the straight hole without reaming. The fit between the back bolt and the hole is a precision tolerance fit, and excessive hole diameter deviation will directly cause anchoring failure. |
| Q2 | How should a failed back bolt pull-out test be handled? For a single failed item, double the sample size and retest; if the retest still fails, the entire batch is judged non-conforming, and all non-conforming anchors must be removed, reinstalled, and re-tested. When non-destructive testing fails, at least 3 additional anchors should be sampled for destructive testing to make the determination. After rectification, confirmation by the design firm and re-acceptance are required. |
| Q3 | Can adhesive injection remedy insufficient drilling accuracy? No. Adhesive injection cannot replace the anchoring function of the mechanical lock. The code requires that adhesive injection into the back bolt hole is an additional safety measure on the premise that the hole diameter is qualified, and it cannot be used as a remedy for out-of-tolerance hole diameters. Out-of-tolerance reamed segment dimensions must be scrapped directly. |
| Q4 | How can failed back bolt pull-out tests be prevented? Use a dedicated back bolt drilling machine; test-drill before production to confirm the hole diameter; check every 30-50 holes with hole-check rods and hole-check gauges; use torque wrenches to control installation torque; and inspect panel quality on arrival. Controlling drilling quality at the source is the key to preventing failures. |
| Q5 | How is the pull-out performance of Daring back bolts? The Daring back bolt dry-hung cladding system has passed the 9-degree rare earthquake test at Tongji University. Daring supplies dedicated inspection tools such as hole-check rods and hole-check gauges, helping installers precisely control drilling quality and reducing the risk of pull-out test failures at the source. |
The Daring back bolt series covers hammer-in, screw-in, cast-in, and high-load back bolts, made of 304/316 stainless steel and achieving stress-free dry-hung anchoring of exterior wall panels through mechanical locking. The Daring back bolt dry-hung cladding system has passed the 9-degree rare earthquake test at Tongji University, and is supplied with hole-check rods and hole-check gauges and other dedicated inspection tools to help installers control drilling quality at the source. For diagnosis and handling advice on back bolt pull-out test issues in a specific project, please contact the Daring technical team.
References
Daring official website: how to drill back bolt holes with qualified dimensions
Daring official website: can a back bolt hole still be used if the diameter is 0.5mm oversize
JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures
JGJ 336-2016 Technical Specification for Artificial Panel Curtain Wall Engineering
GB 50210 Code for Quality Acceptance of Building Decoration Engineering
