The bottom line first:Although chemical anchors and expansion anchors are both commonly used anchor products in post-installed anchoring work, the two have essential differences in load-bearing principle, composition, load capacity, and application scenarios and other aspects. Chemical anchors bond the rod and concrete into one unit through a chemical bonding agent, giving better mechanical performance than expansion anchors of the same size; expansion anchors achieve anchoring through friction generated by mechanical expansion of the expansion sleeve. At the same size, the load-bearing ranking is roughly: chemical anchors > expansion anchors.expansion anchors and ordinary chemical anchors are strictly prohibited in curtain wall load-bearing structures; undercut mechanical anchors or special reverse-cone chemical anchors must be used instead.
In post-installed anchoring work, chemical anchors and expansion anchors are the two most commonly used anchor products. Many designers and installers often face a difficult choice: what is the difference between chemical anchors and expansion anchors, and which is more reliable? This article provides a systematic comparison in terms of load-bearing principle, composition, load capacity, installation conditions, and application scenarios.
1. Basic definitions of chemical anchors and expansion anchors
1.1 Chemical anchors
According to the definition in Annex A.1.4 of JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures, a chemical anchor is an anchor consisting of a metal threaded rod and an anchoring adhesive, which achieves anchoring through the anchoring adhesive. A chemical anchor glues the rod into a drilled hole in the concrete base material using a chemical bonding agent; through the bonding and interlock between the adhesive and the rod and between the adhesive and the concrete hole wall, the fixture is anchored. Chemical anchors belong to chemical bond-type anchors。
1.2 Expansion anchors
The expansion anchor is a type of mechanical anchor. Per the definition in Annex A.1.1 of JGJ 145-2013, a mechanical anchor is an anchor that achieves anchoring through friction or interlock between the anchor and the anchor hole. An expansion anchor presses its expanded end section into the drilled hole wall and carries loads through friction. Its working principle: when the bolt is tightened, the expansion sleeve is squeezed and expanded, generating friction and mechanical interlock against the hole wall and thus achieving anchoring.
2. Core differences between chemical anchors and expansion anchors
| Comparison dimension | Chemical anchor | Expansion anchor |
|---|---|---|
| Anchoring principle | Chemical bonding (adhesive) | Mechanical friction (expansion sleeve expansion) |
| Composition | Threaded rod + nut + washer + chemical agent | Bolt + expansion sleeve |
| Stress on the base material | No stress(no squeezing of the hole wall) | Stress present(expansion force from squeezing the hole wall) |
| Mechanical performance | High(better than expansion anchors at the same size) | Lower |
| Cracked concrete suitability | Ordinary chemical anchors not suitable; special reverse-cone suitable | Not suitable |
| Seismic performance | Load capacity decreases to varying degrees under dynamic loads | Load capacity decreases to varying degrees under dynamic loads |
| High-temperature performance | Limited by the adhesive (prolonged welding not advisable) | No limit(all-metal) |
| Installation waiting time | Requires waiting for adhesive curing | Ready to load immediately |
| Price | Higher | Lower |
| Curtain wall load-bearing suitability | Ordinary chemical anchorsStrictly prohibited | Strictly prohibited |
3. In-depth analysis of load-bearing principles
3.1 Chemical anchors: chemical bonding
A chemical anchor bonds the rod and the concrete hole wall into one unit through a chemical bonding agent (anchoring adhesive). Its load-bearing mechanism: the anchoring adhesive generates both bonding and interlock effects on the rod surface and between the adhesive and the concrete hole wall, transferring loads evenly into the concrete base material. Chemical anchors exert no expansion stress on the base material and cause no squeezing damage to the hole wall, making them suitable for small edge distances and close spacing.
The mechanical performance of chemical anchors is much better than that of expansion anchors of the same size. At the same size, chemical anchors usually outperform expansion anchors in load-bearing.
3.2 Expansion anchors: mechanical friction
Expansion anchors fix by mechanical means. Their working principle: after the expansion sleeve is placed in the drilled hole and the bolt tightened, the sleeve is squeezed and expanded, generating friction and mechanical interlock against the hole wall, thereby fixing the anchor in the base material.
During use, expansion anchors produce stress concentration and exert expansion force on the hole wall. If the base material lacks strength or the edge distance is too small, this can easily cause the concrete to crack or spall. The fixing performance of expansion anchors is strongly affected by hole wall quality; uneven or irregular hole walls easily result in poor fixing.
4. Load capacity comparison
Considering the load-bearing performance of same-size anchors, the approximate ranking is:
Chemical anchors (with injection anchoring adhesive) ≥ > chemical anchors (with chemical capsules) > expansion anchors
From this ranking it can be seen that chemical anchors have better overall load capacity than expansion anchors. Note, however, that the load-bearing performance of chemical anchors is closely related to the type of adhesive used: chemical anchors with injection anchoring adhesive perform best, followed by high-strength chemical anchors with chemical capsules.
Expansion anchors have lower tensile strength, and design loads are usually below the steel's ultimate strength. Under dynamic loads or earthquakes, expansion anchors are prone to pull-through failure with reduced load capacity. Research has noted that expansion anchors fail by pull-out under all conditions, with low load capacity and poor stability.
5. Installation and usage precautions
5.1 Key installation points for chemical anchors
Chemical anchors demand careful installation:
Hole cleaning requirement: the hole must be thoroughly cleaned after drilling; if cleaning cannot meet the requirement, an expansion anchor might as well be used instead
Curing wait: after installation, wait for the adhesive to cure; curing takes even longer at low temperatures
Not suitable for welding: once heated, the chemical agent can easily fail; when fixing with chemical anchors, avoid heating the anchor during welding
Temperature limit: below a certain temperature, the adhesive may fail outright
5.2 Key installation points for expansion anchors
Installing expansion anchors is relatively simple:
Easy installation: no special tools required, suitable for quick fixings
Ready to load immediately: subsequent work can proceed immediately after installation, with no waiting
Base material requirement: the expansion sleeve only works in hard, dense concrete; if the hole wall is loose or cracked, the anchoring force will be significantly reduced
Edge distance requirement: expansion anchors have relatively large edge distance and spacing requirements; otherwise they can easily cause concrete cracking
6. Mandatory requirements for curtain walls and other load-bearing structures
According to the mandatory provisions of JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures and multiple local curtain wall safety documents:
Ordinary expansion anchors:are strictly prohibited in curtain wall load-bearing structures
Ordinary chemical anchors (high-strength chemical anchors):are strictly prohibited in curtain wall load-bearing structures
Permitted anchors: undercut mechanical anchors (such as undercut anchors) and special reverse-cone chemical anchors (capsule chemical anchors)
On building curtain walls in regions such as Shanghai, expansion anchors may not be used. Designs that include expansion anchors will not pass review.
In addition, mixing chemical anchors and expansion anchors on the same curtain wall base plate is strictly prohibited. The two differ greatly in stiffness; under earthquake or typhoon loads, all loads concentrate on the stiffer anchors, the other type carries almost no load, and the overall load capacity is greatly reduced.
7. Selection decision guide
Cases where chemical anchors are preferred
High load capacity requirements: the mechanical performance of chemical anchors is better than that of expansion anchors of the same size
Small edge distance and close spacing conditions: chemical anchors have no expansion stress and do not squeeze or damage the base material
Fixing of important structures: chemical anchors offer better long-term stability and corrosion resistance than expansion bolts
Confidence in installation quality: when holes are thoroughly cleaned and the adhesive fully cures, chemical anchors are more reliable
Cases where expansion anchors are preferred
Fixing of non-load-bearing structures: non-critical locations such as general equipment fixing and pipe supports
Tight schedules: ready to load immediately, no waiting for curing
Cost sensitivity: expansion anchors cost less and offer good value for money
Installation in low-temperature environments: not affected by temperature, whereas chemical anchor adhesives may fail at low temperatures
8. Frequently asked questions
| Q1 | Which is stronger, a chemical anchor or an expansion anchor? At the same size, the mechanical performance of chemical anchors is better than that of expansion anchors. The specific choice depends on the conditions: chemical anchors suit scenarios with high load capacity requirements, expansion anchors suit general non-load-bearing fixings. Both are strictly prohibited in curtain wall load-bearing structures. |
| Q2 | Can chemical anchors and expansion anchors be mixed? Not recommended. The two differ significantly in stiffness, and mixing them causes uneven loading. If mixing is unavoidable, choose groups with similar mechanical performance and ensure the ultimate load capacity of the chemical anchors equals that of the expansion anchors. Mixing on curtain wall base plates is strictly prohibited. |
| Q3 | Why can't expansion anchors be used in curtain walls? Expansion anchors are prone to pull-through failure under dynamic loads or earthquakes, with reduced load capacity; their tensile strength is low; and codes explicitly prohibit their use in seismic fortification areas and load-bearing structures. Regions such as Shanghai have explicitly stipulated that expansion anchors may not be used on curtain walls. |
| Q4 | Can chemical anchors be welded? Generally not recommended. Most chemical anchor agents used in China are epoxy resins with poor high-temperature stability, which are not suitable for welding. If welding is necessary, choose chemical anchors using high-temperature-resistant agents such as vinyl ester resin. |
| Q5 | What anchor products does Daring offer? Daring offers a full range of chemical anchors (high-strength, capsule, special reverse-cone, and dynamic-load reverse-cone anchors) and mechanical anchors (undercut anchors, expansion anchors, etc.). The chemical anchors are paired with Daring's DL-200E modified epoxy injection anchoring adhesive meeting the national Class A adhesive standard, with grade 5.8 or higher carbon steel or 304/316 stainless steel available. For anchor selection advice for a specific project, please contact the Daring technical team. |
Daring offers a full range of chemical anchors (high-strength, capsule, special reverse-cone, and dynamic-load reverse-cone anchors) and mechanical anchors (undercut anchors, expansion anchors, etc.). The chemical anchors are paired with Daring's DL-200E modified epoxy injection anchoring adhesive meeting the national Class A adhesive standard, with grade 5.8 or higher carbon steel or 304/316 stainless steel available; they offer strong bond anchoring, temperature resistance and seismic performance, and suitability for cracked concrete. Expansion anchors are easy to install, ready to load immediately, and affordable, suiting non-load-bearing fixing scenarios. For anchor selection advice for a specific project, please contact the Daring technical team.
References
1. Daring official website — Differences between chemical anchors and mechanical anchors(definitions and load-bearing comparison of chemical and mechanical anchors)
2. Mixing chemical bolts and expansion bolts in post-installed embedment design(feature comparison of chemical and expansion anchors)
3. A look at the differences between chemical anchors and expansion bolts(comparison of principles, composition, and fixing performance)
4. Post-installed anchoring technology types — expansion anchors and bonded anchors(anchor classification and technical principles)
5. JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures(national industry standard)
6. Daring official website — Selection standards for curtain wall anchors(curtain wall prohibitions on expansion anchors and ordinary chemical anchors)
7. "Experimental Study on the Seismic Performance of Anchors" — Earthquake Resistant Engineering and Retrofitting, May 2013 issue(seismic performance test data for expansion and chemical anchors)
