Chemical anchors and mechanical anchors are two different anchoring systems, but in many cases their application ranges overlap. We need to clarify the differences between the two in order to comprehensively select anchors that are safe and cost-effective according to the working conditions.
Definitions of the two
Appendix A of JGJ 145-2013 'Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchorage of Concrete Structures' gives the following definitions of chemical anchors and mechanical anchors:
A.1.4 A chemical anchor is an anchor composed of a metal threaded rod and anchoring adhesive, which forms its anchoring action through the anchoring adhesive.
A.1.1 A mechanical anchor is an anchor that forms its anchorage through friction or key-locking action between the anchor and the anchor hole.
To summarize briefly, as the name suggests, chemical anchors are chemical adhesion anchors, which mainly fix the threaded rod to the concrete by chemical bonding. All non-chemical-adhesion metal anchors are mechanical anchors, which are mainly divided into undercut anchors, expansion anchors, and a rather specialconcrete screw anchor。
Some common anchors
Commonly seen on the market today areClassification of chemical anchorsThere are only three types, namelyhigh-strength chemical anchors、capsule chemical anchorsandreverse-cone chemical anchors. Among these, high-strength chemical anchors are used together with chemical cartridges (they can also be used with injection anchoring adhesive) and account for more than 50% of the total anchor market, representing very large usage. Capsule anchors and reverse-cone anchors need to be used with injection anchoring adhesive; for large-size models, these two types of anchors perform better than high-strength chemical anchors used with chemical cartridges. For details, seeDifferences between high-strength chemical anchors and reverse-cone chemical anchors。
Generally, mechanical anchors are mostly used in projects such as curtain walls, rails, and utility tunnels,Classification of mechanical anchorsIt is fairly simple: undercut anchors have a relatively high safety factor and are mostly used for fixing highly loaded structural components and installing heavy equipment, while expansion anchors are favored by many for their cost-effectiveness. Taking the Anka anchor as an example, its usage is also very large.
Construction cycle
We had intended to discuss the difference in construction convenience between chemical anchors and mechanical anchors, but since construction methods vary considerably among different anchors, it is more appropriate to look at this in terms of construction time.
Chemical anchors achieve anchorage by chemical adhesion, while the chemical resin (used with ordinary high-strength chemical anchors) andinjection anchoring adhesive(generally used with reverse-cone chemical anchors) both require a certain curing time, especially at lower temperatures, when both cure relatively slowly. Moreover, when the temperature drops below a certain point, the adhesive may fail outright. This is the drawback of chemical anchors: a certain waiting time is required after installation, and injection anchoring adhesive has an even longer curing time. For projects with tight schedules, this may not be a good choice.
Mechanical anchors are different: their installation does not involve adhesive curing, so there is no corresponding waiting time, and subsequent operations can be carried out directly after the anchor is installed. Moreover, mechanical anchors do not have to contend with issues such as uneven adhesive mixing or aging during installation, so their service life is theoretically longer.
Comparison of load performance
For anchors, load performance directly determines their use. There is a wide variety of anchors; here, taking anchors of the same specification as an example, we roughly rank their load performance as follows:
Undercut anchor ≈ three types of chemical anchors (when used with injection anchoring adhesive) ≥ self-undercutting anchor ≥ chemical anchor (when used with chemical cartridge) > concrete screw anchor > expansion anchor
This is a rough ranking arrived at after comprehensive consideration and does not apply to all specifications; the specifics depend on the situation. If you are a designer, you can consult Daring to learn about the specific load performance, and then select the appropriate anchor based on the corresponding design values and the solutions provided by Daring.
