Product Knowledge

Grade A adhesives vary in quality too

Views: 0Posted on: 2018-10-26

Many manufacturers on the market produce injection anchoring adhesive, and many have passed grade A adhesive certification. But until you compare, you get a surprise—did you know that grade A adhesives also vary in quality?

Standards for grade A adhesive

The author reviewed multiple national standards and found that two of them mention standards for grade A adhesive. GB 50728-2011 'Technical Code for Safety Appraisal of Structural Strengthening Materials' stipulates:

4.2.2 For room-temperature-curing structural adhesive with concrete as the substrate, its safety appraisal shall include basic performance appraisal, long-term service performance appraisal, and resistance to medium erosion appraisal. When conducting the appraisal, the following provisions of this section shall be observed:

1 The basic performance of structural adhesive shall comply with the requirements of Table 4.2.2-1, Table 4.2.2-2, or Table 4.2.2-3, respectively;

Table 4.2.2-3 Basic performance appraisal requirements for structural adhesive used for anchoring with concrete as the substrate

Inspection item

Inspection conditions

Appraisal qualification index

IClass adhesive

IIClass adhesive

IIIClass adhesive

AGrade

B

Grade

Adhesive properties

Splitting tensile strength (MPa)

Tested at (23±2)℃ and (50±5)% RH at a loading rate of 2 mm/min

≥8.5

≥7.0

≥10

≥12

Flexural strength (MPa)

≥50

≥40

≥10

≥12

and shall not fail in a brittle, fragmented manner

Compressive strength (MPa)

≥60

Bonding ability

Steel-to-steel tensile shear strength (MPa)

Standard value

(23±2)℃、(50±5)%RH

≥10

≥8

≥12

Average value

(60±2)℃、10min

≥11

≥9



(95±2)℃、10min



≥11

—

(125±3)℃、10min




≥10

(-45±2)℃、30min

≥12

≥10

≥13

Bond strength between ribbed steel bar (or full threaded rod) and concrete under confined pull-out conditions

(23±2)℃、(50±5)%RH

C30

≥11

≥8.5

≥11

≥12

Φ25

l=150

C60

≥17

≥14

≥17

≥18

Φ25

l=125

Steel-to-steel T-impact peeling length (mm)

(23±2)℃、(50±5)%RH

≤25

≤40

≤20

Heat deflection temperature (℃)

Method B using a bending stress of 0.45 MPa

≥65

≥60

≥100

≥130

Non-volatile matter content (%)

(105±2)℃、(180±5)min

≥99


In addition, injection anchoring adhesives are all organic anchoring adhesives. According to clause 5.1 of JG/T 340-2011 'Anchoring Adhesive for Concrete Structure Engineering':

The requirements for organic anchoring adhesives shall comply with the provisions of Table 1:

Table 1 Requirements for organic anchoring adhesives

No.

Item

Requirement

AGrade adhesive

BGrade adhesive

1

Appearance quality

No separation, agglomeration, or sedimentation

2

Sag flow / min

No dripping, ≤10

3

Pot life / min

Fast-setting type

10~25

Non-fast-setting type

25~100

4

Service temperature range

Meet the service temperature range stated in the product specification

5

Ethylenediamine content in the curing agent / %

≤0.1

6

Non-volatile matter content / %

≥99

7

Bonding performance

Steel-to-steel tensile shear strength standard value / MPa

≥16.0

≥13.0

Bond strength between ribbed steel bar and concrete under confined pull-out conditions / MPa

C30Concrete

≥11.0

≥8.5

C60Concrete

≥17.0

≥14.0

8

Durability

Resistance to damp-heat aging, reduction rate of steel-to-steel tensile shear strength standard value / %

≤10

≤15

Freeze-thaw resistance, reduction rate of steel-to-steel tensile shear strength standard value a / %

≤5

Fatigue test b / 10,000 cycles

≥200

—

aThis item is tested for anchoring adhesives used in cold and severe cold regions and where required by the user.

bThis item is tested for anchoring adhesives used in railway engineering, bridge engineering, and where required by the user.








The above are the basic performance test items for injection anchoring adhesive. However, the author examined two standards and found certain differences between them, but the testing standard used by third-party testing institutions is GB 50728-2011 'Technical Code for Safety Appraisal of Structural Strengthening Materials'.

Comparison of different grade A adhesives

Here, two injection anchoring adhesives available on the market are taken as examples to compare the differences in their grade A adhesive reports.

Test report of anchoring adhesive from a certain brand A

Figure 1. Test report of adhesive from an imported brand A (remove upon request)

Test report of anchoring adhesive from a certain brand B

Figure 2. Test report of adhesive from an imported brand B (remove upon request)

A careful comparison of the test parameters of the two reveals huge differences in results for the same test items, with some results differing by as much as 100%. If you are a designer, you can compare the parameters in various adhesive test reports to determine the overall performance of the adhesive.

Other tests for injection anchoring adhesive

In fact,grade A adhesive is only one basic test for injection anchoring adhesive, and GB 50728-2011 'Technical Code for Safety Appraisal of Structural Strengthening Materials' also has the following standards:

2 The appraisal of long-term service performance of structural adhesive shall comply with the following requirements in Table 4.2.2-4:

1) Structural adhesive with a design service life of 30 years shall pass the damp-heat aging resistance test;

2) Structural adhesive with a design service life of 50 years shall pass both the damp-heat aging resistance test and the long-term stress resistance test;

3) Structural adhesive subjected to dynamic loads shall pass the fatigue resistance test;

4) Anchoring adhesive used in cold regions shall pass the freeze-thaw resistance test.

3 The resistance of structural adhesive to medium erosion shall comply with the requirements of Table 4.2.2-5.

4.2.2-4 Standard for appraisal of long-term service performance of structural adhesive with concrete as the substrate

Test item

Inspection conditions

Appraisal qualification index

IClass adhesive

IIClass adhesive

IIIClass adhesive

AGrade

BGrade

Resistance to environmental action

Resistance to damp-heat aging

After aging at 50℃ and 95% RH for 90 d (60 d for grade B adhesive), cool to room temperature and conduct a steel-to-steel tensile shear test

Compared with short-term test results at room temperature, the reduction rate of its shear strength (%):

≤12

≤18

≤10

≤12

Resistance to heat aging

After aging for 30 d in the following temperature environments, conduct steel-to-steel tensile shear tests at the same temperature

Compared with 10 min short-term test results at the same temperature, the reduction rate of its shear strength:

(80±2)℃

≤5

Not required

—

—

(95±2)℃

—

—

≤5

—

(125±3)℃

—

—

—

≤5

Freeze-thaw resistance

At -25℃⇋35℃freeze-thaw cycling temperature, with each cycle lasting 8 h; after 50 cycles, conduct a steel-to-steel tensile shear test at room temperature

Compared with short-term test results at room temperature, the reduction rate of its shear strength shall be no more than 5%

Resistance to stress

Resistance to long-term stress

Subjected to a 4.0 MPa shear stress continuously for 210 d in an environment of (23±2)℃ and (50±5)% RH

No failure in steel-to-steel tensile shear over time, and the creep deformation value is less than 0.4 mm

Resistance to fatigue stress

At room temperature, conduct steel-to-steel tensile shear tests under a fatigue load with a frequency of 5 Hz, a stress ratio of 5:1.5, and a maximum stress of 4.0 MPa

After 2×10⁶ cycles of constant-amplitude sinusoidal fatigue loading, the specimen does not fail

Note: If, before applying for safety appraisal, relevant research institutions have been entrusted to complete verification tests and conformity assessment of the long-term stress resistance of this brand of structural adhesive, and the assessment report has been reviewed by the safety appraisal institution, this test may be waived and a wedge rapid determination (Appendix C) performed instead.

Table 4.2.2-5 Appraisal standard for resistance of structural adhesive to medium erosion with concrete as the substrate

Performance to be inspected

Medium environment and treatment requirements

Appraisal qualification index

Strength reduction rate compared with the control group (%)

Appearance quality requirements after treatment

Resistance to salt spray

5%NaClSolution; spray pressure 0.08 MPa; test temperature (35±2)℃; spray once every 0.5 h, each time for 0.5 h; the salt spray should settle freely on the specimen; duration of action: 90 d for grade A adhesive and type II and III adhesives; 60 d for grade B adhesive; upon expiry, conduct a steel-to-steel tensile shear strength test

≤5

No cracks or debonding allowed

Resistance to seawater immersion (only for underwater structural adhesive)

Seawater or artificial seawater; test temperature (35±2)℃; immersion time: 90 d for grade A adhesive; 60 d for grade B adhesive; upon expiry, conduct a steel-to-steel tensile shear strength test

≤7

No cracks or debonding allowed

Resistance to alkaline media

CaSaturated Ca(OH)2 solution; test temperature (35±2)℃; immersion time: 60 d for grade A adhesive and type II and III adhesives; 45 d for grade B adhesive; upon expiry, conduct a steel-to-concrete tensile bond strength test

No reduction, and failure is in the concrete

No cracks, peeling, or blistering allowed

Resistance to acidic media

5%H2SO4Solution; test temperature (35±2)℃; immersion time: 30 d for all types of adhesive; upon expiry, conduct a steel-to-concrete tensile bond strength test

Concrete failure

No cracks or debonding allowed

According to the above description,Injection anchoring adhesive may also need tests for resistance to damp-heat aging, resistance to long-term stress, fatigue resistance, and freeze-thaw resistance; some special working conditions may even require testing of resistance to medium erosion. These working conditions need to be considered when designing a project; grade A adhesive is not the only standard.



Back to Daring Home  Back to Top