Conclusion first:Although both expansion anchors and undercut anchors are mechanical anchors,they work on completely different principles and are suitable for different applications. Expansion anchors rely onfriction load resistance, generating expansion stress on the hole wall after installation; undercut anchors rely onmechanical locking load resistance, forming an interlocking mechanism through undercutting at the bottom of the hole. At the standards level,undercut anchors must be used for load-bearing structures, and expansion anchors are strictly prohibited. For the same specification, the load capacity of undercut anchors can reachmore than 2 timesthat of expansion anchors, and it is necessary to use
In building post-installed anchoring work, expansion anchors and undercut anchors are the two mechanical anchor products most easily confused. Because of their similar appearance, many construction workers often use undercut anchors as expansion anchors, or use expansion anchors in load-bearing structures where they should not be used, causing serious safety hazards. This article comprehensively analyzes the differences between the two from multiple perspectives — working principle, load capacity, construction process, and standard requirements — to help engineering personnel make informed selections.
I. What Are Expansion Anchors and Undercut Anchors?
1.1 Expansion Anchors (Expansion-Type Anchors)
Expansion anchors are mechanical anchors that rely on the expansion pieces on the anchor to generatefrictionagainst the hole wall for anchoring. Their working principle is as follows: the expansion bolt is placed into a pre-drilled straight hole, and when the nut is tightened, the expansion body (sleeve or expansion plates) is compressed against the hole wall, generating pull-out resistance through the friction coefficient between concrete and metal.
There are many types of expansion anchors; common ones includeAnka anchors (machined wedge anchors), drop-in anchors, and sleeve expansion anchorsare all expansion anchors. These anchors are simple to install and quick to fit, but their load-bearing behavior involves considerable uncertainty. Daring's mechanical anchor series covers multiple categories such as drop-in, Anka, and sleeve expansion anchors.
1.2 Undercut Anchors (Undercut-Type Anchors)
Undercut anchors are also known asmold-undercut anchors and post-cut undercut anchors, referring to anchors that, after a straight hole is drilled in the concrete substrate, at the bottom of the holeare reamed again, with the reamed cavity and the expanded keys of the anchor formingan interlocking mechanism, to achieve a post-installed anchoring connection. Their load-bearing mode ismechanical locking load resistance, with an anchoring principle similar to the stress distribution of cast-in foundation bolts.
Depending on their construction, undercut anchors are further divided intoself-undercutting, mold-undercutting, and adhesive-mold-undercuttingthree types. Daring undercut anchors are made of carbon steel of grade 5.8 or above or 304/316 stainless steel, and comply with JGJ 145-2013.
II. Expansion Anchors vs. Undercut Anchors: A Comprehensive Comparison Across Seven Dimensions
| Comparison dimension | Expansion anchors | Undercut anchors |
|---|---|---|
| Load-bearing principle | Friction load resistance (expansion pressing against the hole wall) | Mechanical locking load resistance (interlock via reaming) |
| Typical load capacity of M12 | approx. 30 kN (anchor pull-out) | ≥60 kN (anchor tensile failure) |
| Substrate stress | Expansion stress present, easily causing substrate cracking | No expansion stress, gentle on the substrate |
| Seismic performance | load capacity reduced under dynamic loads | load capacity essentially unaffected by dynamic loads |
| Fatigue/vibration stability | prone to slipping or even pulling out under vibration | no slipping risk, approaching the performance of cast-in anchors |
| Construction process | Drilling → hole cleaning → installation (one-step) | Drilling → reaming → hole cleaning → installation (requires secondary reaming) |
| Suitability for load-bearing structures | Strictly prohibited | Mandatory |
III. In-Depth Analysis of Core Differences
3.1 Load-Bearing Principle: Friction vs. Locking — the Fundamental Difference
The most fundamental difference between the two types of anchors lies inthe load-bearing principle. Expansion anchors resist pull-out through thefrictionbetween the expansion sleeve and the hole wall; this friction depends on the compression of the expansion sleeve against the hole wall. Once the substrate cracks or is subjected to vibration, the friction drops significantly and the anchor may slip or even pull out.
Undercut anchors are completely different. Theypre-ream the bottom of the hole, so that the expanded keys at the anchor base forma mechanical interlockwith the reamed cavity, with a load-bearing mode similar to that of cast-in foundation bolts. This locking structuredoes not rely on friction, and maintains stable anchoring capacity even if the substrate cracks.
In simple terms, an expansion anchor is "wedged in" while an undercut anchor is "locked in." One relies on friction, the other on mechanical locking.
3.2 Load Capacity: Undercut Anchors Can Reach 2-3 Times That of Expansion Anchors
Under the same specification, substrate, and embedment depth, the effective load capacity of undercut anchors can reach2 to 3 timesthat of ordinary expansion anchors. Taking M12 as an example:
Expansion anchors: ultimate pull-out capacity of approximately 30 kN, with failure usually occurring by anchor pull-out
Undercut anchors: ultimate pull-out capacity of over 60 kN, with failure occurring by tensile rupture of the anchor
The load on an undercut anchor can generally reach the ultimate strength of the anchor material, whereas the friction-based load resistance of expansion anchors involves considerable uncertainty, with the average load being as low as half that of an undercut anchor of the same specification.
3.3 Seismic and Fatigue Resistance: Undercut Anchors Have Significant Advantages
Under dynamic loads, expansion anchorsexperience varying degrees of reduction in ultimate load capacity, and are prone toslipping or even pulling outunder fatigue loads and vibration. This is one of the biggest hidden risks of expansion anchors.
The ultimate load capacity of undercut anchorsis essentially unaffected by dynamic loading. Daring undercut anchors have passed seismic tests at the building materials testing center and offer excellent seismic performance. By creating a load-bearing state similar to that of cast-in inserts, undercut anchors aim foran anchoring effect that comes infinitely close tothat of cast-in anchors.
3.4 Construction Process: Undercut Anchors Involve More Steps
The installation of expansion anchors is relatively simple:drilling → hole cleaning → installation, completed in three steps with no need to wait for curing.
The installation of undercut anchors is more complex:
Step 1: use a straight-hole drill bit to drill a hole of the corresponding diameter and depth
Step 2: use a dedicated undercutting drill bit to ream the bottom of the hole, forming a wedge-shaped cavity
Step 3: use a dust blower until no dust remains in the hole
Step 4: strike the anchor with a hammer or rotary hammer via a striking sleeve so that the bottom expands to complete the anchoring
Undercut anchors requiresecondary reaming, and must usea dedicated undercutting drill bit. Daring supplies original undercutting drill bits for its undercut anchors to ensure the desired reaming result. Installation requires five tools: a rotary hammer, straight-hole drill bit, reaming drill bit, dust blower, and striking sleeve.
3.5 Visual Identification: Sleeve Wall Thickness Is Key
Expansion anchors and undercut anchors of similar appearance exist on the market and are easily confused. Thekey visual difference between the two is the sleeve wall thickness:
Expansion anchors: thinner sleeve wall
Undercut anchors: thicker sleeve wall
It is important to note thatif an undercut anchor is used as an expansion anchor (installed directly without reaming), its load resistance is even lower than that of an expansion anchor—the thicker wall prevents expansion. Undercut anchors can only deliver their intended anchoring performance after the hole has been reamed.
IV. Mandatory Standard Requirements: Undercut Anchors Are Required for Load-Bearing Structures
According toGB 50367-2013 Code for Design of Strengthening Concrete StructuresandJGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring of Concrete Structures, the following requirements apply:
mechanical anchors used in load-bearing structures shall be undercut anchors with a locking effect, and expansion anchors shall not be used
Depending on their construction, undercut anchors are divided intoself-undercutting, mold-undercutting, and adhesive-mold-undercuttingthree types
in structures in seismic fortification zones and in components directly subjected to dynamic loads, expansion anchors shall not be usedas connectors for load-bearing structures
Undercut anchors shall meet the relevant requirements ofJGJ 145-2013, and shall be selected from anchorssuitable for cracked concreteand capable of resisting seismic actions.
In summary: expansion anchors must not be used in load-bearing structures; undercut anchors or special reverse-cone chemical anchors must be used.
V. Selection Decision Guide
When to Prefer Expansion Anchors
Fixing of non-load-bearing structures: general equipment fixing, pipe supports, guardrail installation, etc.
Tight schedules requiring fast installation: expansion anchors are ready to use immediately, with no curing wait
Cost-sensitive projects: expansion anchors are relatively inexpensive
Temporary fixing or removable applications: expansion anchors are relatively easy to remove
Non-critical components in non-seismic zones
When Undercut Anchors Must Be Used
Load-bearing structures: GB 50367-2013 mandates the use of undercut anchors
Seismic fortification zones: standards explicitly prohibit expansion anchors in load-bearing structures in seismic zones
Components directly subjected to dynamic loads: such as mechanical equipment foundations and bridge auxiliary structures
Cracked concrete substrates: undercut anchors are suitable for cracked concrete
Curtain wall projects: curtain wall codes explicitly require undercut anchors for embedded plates
Applications with extremely high anchoring reliability requirements: undercut anchors offer high load capacity and excellent seismic and fatigue resistance
VI. FAQ
| Q1 | Which is stronger, expansion anchors or undercut anchors? Undercut anchors are stronger. For the same specification, their load capacity can reach 2-3 times that of expansion anchors. Taking M12 as an example, undercut anchors have an ultimate pull-out capacity of ≥60 kN (anchor tensile failure), while expansion anchors have approximately 30 kN (anchor pull-out). |
| Q2 | Can expansion anchors be used in load-bearing structures? No. GB 50367-2013 explicitly stipulates that mechanical anchors used in load-bearing structures shall be undercut anchors with a locking effect, and expansion anchors shall not be used. Expansion anchors are likewise strictly prohibited in seismic fortification zones and in components directly subjected to dynamic loads. |
| Q3 | What is the difference between undercut anchors and self-undercutting anchors? Undercut anchors require drilling a straight hole first and then reaming separately; the process is more complex but the reaming is thorough and the safety factor is high. Self-undercutting anchors complete the reaming during installation and are simpler to install. The two have similar mechanical properties, but undercut anchors are generally available in smaller sizes (M20 and above are less common). |
| Q4 | Why is the installation of undercut anchors more complex than that of expansion anchors? Undercut anchors require a secondary reaming step, using a dedicated undercutting drill bit to create a wedge-shaped cavity at the bottom of the hole. If rebar is encountered during reaming, the hole cannot be reamed properly, especially for large-size anchors. Installation requires five tools: a rotary hammer, straight-hole drill bit, reaming drill bit, dust blower, and striking sleeve. |
| Q5 | What undercut anchor products does Daring offer? Daring's mechanical anchor series covers multiple categories including undercut, self-undercutting, drop-in, Anka, and heavy-duty mechanical anchors, made of carbon steel/stainless steel with various coating processes. Daring undercut anchors are made of carbon steel of grade 5.8 or above or 304/316 stainless steel and are supplied with original undercutting drill bits and electric installation tools. The products comply with JGJ 145-2013, GB/T 16938-2008, and other standards. |
Daring's mechanical anchor series covers multiple categories including undercut, self-undercutting, drop-in, Anka, and heavy-duty mechanical anchors, made of carbon steel/stainless steel with various coating processes, achievinginstant locking upon installation with no curing required, with high load capacity, seismic and fatigue resistance, and compatibility with a variety of substrates such as cracked/non-cracked concrete and natural stone. Daring undercut anchors have passed seismic tests at the building materials testing center and comply with JGJ 145-2013. For anchor selection recommendations for specific projects, please consult the Daring technical team.
