Projects today distinguish between cast-in (pre-installed) inserts and post-installed inserts, but many people do not understand the difference. Here we explain it in simple terms.
How they are classified
As the name suggests, cast-in inserts are pre-embedded structural components placed before the concrete is poured and ready for use once the concrete has been cast. They fall into two types: cast-in channels and plate-type inserts. Cast-in channels use a two-point fixing method, while plate-type inserts mostly use four-point fixing; the difference will be covered later. Post-installed inserts are structural components whose anchoring effect is achieved by drilling holes and setting anchors after the concrete has been cast. All post-installed inserts are curtain wall anchors, and curtain wall anchor selection must comply with national or local codes.
Which is the orthodox approach?
If you understand why post-installed inserts exist, you will know which approach is more orthodox. For reasonably formal projects, drawings and plans are required before civil works begin, and the initial plan is usually a cast-in plan—that is, cast-in inserts. Post-installed inserts are used during construction mostly because of later design changes or errors in cast-in insert positioning. Therefore, cast-in inserts are the more orthodox approach.
Yet you will find that in actual construction, far fewer projects use cast-in inserts than post-installed ones. Possible reasons for this are as follows:
1. Design changes. Some projects have extremely short cycles from design to construction, and plans may change during construction, making the originally designed cast-in approach unworkable and forcing the use of post-installed inserts.
2. Cost savings. Some projects are designed from the outset to use post-installed inserts, which saves design costs and speeds up the schedule. On the other hand, the overall cost of materials and construction for cast-in inserts is higher than for post-installed ones, which may be the main reason why post-installed inserts are used in such a high overall proportion.In my view, this approach to construction really puts the cart before the horse.
Advantages of cast-in inserts
Precisely because cast-in inserts offer more safety-related benefits, they are the installation method strongly recommended by codes. Compared with post-installed inserts, they have the following advantages:
1. No subsequent welding, no fire hazard, and no loss of mechanical performance. Conversely, when high-strength chemical anchors—which hold an extremely high market share—are used as the mainstay of post-installed inserts, some manufacturers' chemical anchors suffer significant stability loss after welding.
2. Relatively stable quality and higher overall quality than post-installed inserts. Post-installed inserts hold a high market share, but their overall quality is uneven and mostly poor, so it is genuinely difficult for purchasers to source good post-installed inserts. By comparison, the overall quality of cast-in inserts is easier to control.
3. No destructive operations on the concrete and relatively safer construction. Cast-in work is completed once the concrete is poured. For post-installed inserts, however, anchor installation requires a degree of skill and patience—hole cleaning for chemical anchors and reaming for undercut anchors are common installation pitfalls, and such fatal errors often substantially reduce the safety of the entire exterior wall structure.
Post-installed inserts, on the other hand, have no positioning-offset problem: holes are drilled and anchors are installed on site and can be executed as required. This is their relative advantage, and something cast-in inserts cannot fully achieve. In my view, for safety reasons, cast-in inserts should be used on curtain walls wherever possible; post-installed inserts should be the choice only when there is no alternative.
