Product Knowledge

The difference between chemical and expansion anchors

Views: 0Posted on: 2018-12-26

Chemical anchors and expansion anchors belong to different anchor systems. Anyone searching for this question has surely encountered both types of anchors in a project; in their minds, chemical anchors specifically refer to high-strength chemical anchors, while expansion anchors refer to sleeve expansion anchors.

Compared with other anchors, the price gap between these two types is small, and both are relatively low-priced, so most relatively low-end domestic projects use these two types of anchors. Many people do not understand the difference between them, so here we provide a brief explanation.

Appendix A of JGJ 145-2013 Technical Specification for Post-Installed Anchoring in Concrete Structures defines chemical anchors and mechanical anchors as follows:

A.1.4 A chemical anchor is an anchor composed of a metal threaded rod and anchoring adhesive, which achieves anchoring through the anchoring adhesive.

A.1.1 A mechanical anchor is an anchor that achieves anchoring through friction or interlock between the anchor and the drilled hole.

The high-strength chemical anchor mentioned above is one type of chemical anchor, while the sleeve expansion anchor is one type of mechanical anchor. Chemical anchors are mostly used with chemical capsules, whose bonding effect and stability are slightly inferior to injection anchoring adhesives; the sleeve expansion anchor works on the principle of friction to achieve anchoring, and its anchoring effect is slightly inferior to anchoring formed by interlock. Simply put, neither is the best product in its own category, but there is still a considerable difference between the two.

A large gap in load performance

Market prices of chemical anchors vary widely, and so does their load performance. Take Daring's high-strength chemical anchor as an example: the commonly used grade 5.8 carbon steel M12×160 high-strength chemical anchor with a chemical capsule can reach an ultimate pull-out force of over 60kN, with the test result being rod breakage. This is top-tier in the market, and it is hard to find an identical anchor with better performance than Daring's. The same M12 sleeve expansion anchor, at an embedment depth of about 100mm, has an ultimate pull-out force of less than 40kN, with the test result being the anchor being pulled out.

From the above we know that the pull-out force of some commonly used high-strength chemical anchors can reach the ultimate strength of the steel in the current specification, thereforeThe pull-out force of high-strength chemical anchors is generally better than that of sleeve expansion anchors. However, the adhesive carries the risk of aging, so their stability is not as good as that of sleeve expansion anchors.

A certain gap in construction period

Both are fairly simple to install, but after installing a sleeve expansion anchor, other structures can be anchored immediately without waiting, whereas a chemical anchor requires waiting for the adhesive to cure before continuing work, which is not a good choice for projects with tight schedules. In addition,when the substrate temperature is low (around 0°C), the curing time of chemical anchors can reach several hours, which is unfriendly to construction scheduling; when the substrate temperature is below -5°C, the chemical capsule will fail, and using chemical anchors then poses safety risks.Therefore,in low-temperature environments, sleeve expansion anchors may be more popular for projects.

What the two have in common

The author reviewed multiple codes, and GB 50367-2013 Design Code for Strengthening Concrete Structures contains the following provisions:

16.1.3 Mechanical anchors used in load-bearing structures shall be post-installed undercut anchors with an interlock effect. According to how their structure is formed, these anchors are further divided into three types: self-undercutting, mold-undercutting, and adhesive-mold-undercutting. Adhesive anchors used in load-bearing structures shall be special reverse-cone adhesive anchors. Self-tapping screws do not belong to the anchor system and shall not be designed or calculated as anchors.

16.1.4 Expansion anchors shall not be used as connectors for load-bearing structures in structures located in seismic fortification zones, or in members directly subjected to dynamic loads.

That is to say,neither high-strength chemical anchors nor sleeve expansion anchors may be used on load-bearing structures.

Back to Daring Home  Back to Top