The bottom line:Channel-type and plate-type cast-in inserts are the two most mainstream types of inserts in curtain wall projects, and their core differences lie instructural form, load capacity and cost. A channel-type insert consists ofa hot-rolled channel plus anchor bars (rebar anchors). It is compact and lightweight (about 2 kg), and its cost is abouthalf that of a plate-type insert, or even less, making it suitable for conventional curtain walls, utility tunnels, tunnels, thin-plate structures and similar applications. A plate-type insert consists ofan anchor plate plus rebar anchors and channel steel. It is bulky and heavy (about 6 kg), but itsload capacity is far higher than that of channel-type inserts(tensile load capacity up to 140 kN, more than 4 times that of the channel type), making it suitable for long-span curtain walls, high-end curtain walls, steel-reinforced concrete structures and heavy-load applications. Daring offers both channel-type inserts (welded and riveted processes) and plate-slot cast-in channels (weld-free plate channel, Type A and Type B), and can provide customized selection recommendations based on project conditions.
In curtain wall, metro tunnel and urban utility tunnel projects, insert selection directly affects the safety, durability and cost of the anchoring system. Many designers and engineers lack a systematic understanding of the differences between channel-type and plate-type inserts in terms of cost and applicable scenarios, so selection deviations occur frequently. This article provides a comprehensive analysis from the perspectives of structural composition, cost comparison, load capacity and application scenarios, and gives selection recommendations based on Daring's product line.
I. Basic definitions of channel-type and plate-type inserts
1.1 Channel-type insert (cast-in channel)
A channel-type insert, also known as a cast-in channel, consists ofa hot-rolled channel (C-shaped channel steel) and anchor bars (rebar anchors). It is embedded in the structure when the concrete is poured, eliminating the hassle of post-installed anchoring and providing better load-bearing performance. Daring channel-type inserts are made of Q355 steel or 304/316 stainless steel and are available inriveted and weldedprocesses.
The typical structure of a channel-type insert includes: hot-rolled channel steel (channel opening sizes such as 50×25, 50×30 and 52×34), I-shaped or T-shaped anchor bars, and matching T-head bolts. During concrete pouring, thefiller foam and end capinside the channel effectively prevent concrete from flowing in and causing blockage, ensuring subsequent installation of the T-head bolt.
1.2 Plate-type insert (plate-slot cast-in channel)
A plate-type insert (also known as a plate-slot cast-in channel) refers toan insert with holes on the surface of the anchor plate, channel steel welded on the back to restrict bolt head rotation, and symmetrical rebar anchors. Daring plate-slot cast-in channels (weld-free plate channel) featureintegral forming of Q355B hot-rolled channel steel and steel plate, with no on-site welding required.
The typical structure of a plate-slot cast-in channel includes: hot-rolled channel steel, steel plate (anchor plate), symmetrical rebar anchors, through bolts and matching T-head bolts. Daring plate-slot cast-in channels are available inType A and Type Bversions: Type A is mainly used for non-welded cast-in anchoring applications with high mechanical performance requirements; Type B is mainly used for non-welded anchoring in steel-reinforced concrete with high mechanical performance requirements.
II. Cost comparison: clear advantages of channel-type inserts
2.1 Per-unit cost comparison
| Comparison item | Channel-type insert | Plate-type insert |
|---|---|---|
| Unit weight | About 2 kg | About 6 kg |
| Unit price (reference) | About 25 RMB per set | About 60 RMB per set |
| Cost comparison | Baseline (1x) | More than 2x the channel type |
In terms of unit cost, the price of a channel-type insert is abouthalf that of a plate-type insert, or even less. A channel-type insert weighs about 2 kg, and with two T-head bolts added, a set costs about 25 RMB. A plate-type insert weighs about 6 kg and costs about 60 RMB. This means that for the same quantity, channel-type inserts can reduce project costs bymore than 50%。
2.2 Processing efficiency and labor cost
The processing technology of channel-type inserts is relatively simple and quality inspection is easy. Processing one channel-type insert takes about5 minutes, while processing one plate-type insert takes about20 minutes, so the processing efficiency of channel-type inserts is about3 timesthat of plate-type inserts. The improved processing efficiency directly reduces labor costs.
2.3 Construction and installation cost
Channel-type inserts are compact and very convenient to install. The rebar anchors of a channel-type insert are arranged in a single row, and the channel steel is small, so it rarely interferes with the rebar of the main structure, keeping the construction period short. Plate-type inserts occupy a large volume, and their rebar anchors are usually arranged in two rows and two columns, which interferes easily with the main rebar of the main structure. In addition, the channel-type insert is connected to the curtain wall sub-frame adapter via T-head bolts,requiring no on-site weldingand making installation very easy; plate-type inserts, by contrast, require welding for fixation after adjustment, increasing on-site construction difficulty and fire risk.
III. Load capacity comparison: significant advantages of plate-type inserts
3.1 Load capacity data comparison
| Load capacity indicator | Channel-type insert | Plate-type insert |
|---|---|---|
| Design tensile load capacity | About 32 kN | About 140 kN |
| Design shear load capacity | About 23 kN | About 55 kN |
| Load capacity multiple | Baseline (1x) | About 4.4x in tension and about 2.4x in shear |
Plate-type inserts have far higher load capacity than channel-type inserts. The design tensile load capacity of a channel-type insert is 32 kN and its design shear load capacity is 23 kN, while a plate-type insert has a design tensile load capacity of 140 kN and a design shear load capacity of about 55 kN. Therefore, when the curtain wall span is large, or the curtain wall face is far from the structural face,plate-type inserts are the only option。
IV. Application scenario comparison
| Application scenario | Recommended product | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Conventional building curtain walls | Channel-type insert | Load capacity meets requirements; low cost and high construction efficiency |
| Metro tunnels and urban utility tunnels | Channel-type insert | Compact, unlikely to interfere with rebar, easy three-dimensional adjustment |
| Thin-plate main structures | Channel-type insert | When the main structure is a relatively thin plate structure,channel-type inserts are the only option |
| Long-span curtain walls | Plate-type insert | Channel-type capacity is insufficient; the plate type must be used |
| Curtain wall face far from the structural face | Plate-type insert | Higher bending and tensile load capacity is required |
| High-end curtain walls and steel-reinforced concrete structures | Plate-type insert | High mechanical performance requirements; high load capacity needed |
| Heavy equipment fixing | Plate-type insert | Load capacity requirements exceed the applicable range of channel-type inserts |
4.1 Typical application scenarios for channel-type inserts
Conventional building curtain walls: Exposed-frame curtain walls, hidden-frame curtain walls, stone curtain walls, etc.
Metro tunnel projects: Overhead contact line suspension, pipe supports, etc.
Urban utility tunnels: Pipeline supports, equipment fixing, etc.
Thin-plate structures: When the main structure is a relatively thin plate structure, channel-type inserts are compact and highly adaptable
Cost-sensitive projects: Channel-type inserts offer high processing efficiency and excellent value for money
4.2 Typical application scenarios for plate-type inserts
Long-span curtain walls: For larger curtain wall spans, plate-type inserts offer higher load capacity
High-end curtain wall projects: Curtain wall projects with high mechanical performance requirements
Steel-reinforced concrete structures: Applications with extremely high anchoring strength requirements
Curtain wall face far from the structural face: Higher bending and tensile load capacity is required
Pursuing weld-free construction: Daring plate-slot cast-in channels require no on-site welding, eliminating fire hazards
V. Daring selection recommendations
5.1 Advantages of Daring channel-type inserts
Daring channel-type inserts are formed in one pass by hot rolling and made of Q355 steel or 304/316 stainless steel, with welded and riveted processes available. The products have passed testing at the National Building Materials Testing Center for2 million cycles of fatigue resistance, fire resistanceand other items. Paired with T-head bolts, they enable flexible three-dimensional adjustment. The filler foam and end cap inside the channel effectively prevent concrete from flowing in, ensuring subsequent installation of the T-head bolt.
5.2 Advantages of Daring plate-slot cast-in channels
Daring plate-slot cast-in channels (weld-free plate channel) are formed integrally from Q355B hot-rolled channel steel and steel plate, with no on-site welding. The Type B plate-slot cast-in channel is made of grade 8.8 Q355 carbon steel with a hot-dip galvanized surface; the zinc coating thickness reaches 70 μm, giving an outdoor service life of about 50 years, and 304 and 316 stainless steel options are also available. Thanks to a larger load-bearing area, its load capacity is far higher than that of ordinary channel-type inserts, and it is mostly used in projects where channel-type inserts provide insufficient capacity and the concrete layer is relatively thin.
5.3 Daring selection decision table
| Project characteristics | Recommended product | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Conventional curtain walls, utility tunnels, tunnels | Channel-type insert | High versatility and cost-effectiveness |
| Thin-plate main structure | Channel-type insert | Compact; only the channel type can be used |
| Long-span and high-end curtain walls | Plate-slot cast-in channel | Higher load capacity and better load-bearing performance |
| Steel-reinforced concrete structures | Type B plate-slot | Specifically designed for steel-reinforced concrete |
| Weld-free construction requirements | Weld-free plate channel | Integral forming, eliminating fire hazards |
VI. Frequently asked questions
| Q1 | What is the cost difference between channel-type and plate-type inserts? A channel-type insert weighs about 2 kg per piece and costs about 25 RMB per set; a plate-type insert weighs about 6 kg per piece and costs about 60 RMB per set. The cost of a channel-type insert is about half that of a plate-type insert or even less, and its processing efficiency is about 3 times that of the plate type. |
| Q2 | How large is the load capacity gap between channel-type and plate-type inserts? The design tensile load capacity of a channel-type insert is about 32 kN and its design shear load capacity is about 23 kN, while a plate-type insert has a design tensile load capacity of about 140 kN and a design shear load capacity of about 55 kN. The tensile load capacity of the plate type is about 4.4 times that of the channel type. |
| Q3 | When must plate-type inserts be used? Plate-type inserts must be used when load capacity requirements exceed the applicable range of channel-type inserts, such as long-span curtain walls, curtain wall faces far from the structural face, high-end curtain walls, steel-reinforced concrete structures and heavy equipment fixing. |
| Q3 | Why can only channel-type inserts be used for thin-plate main structures? When the main structure is a relatively thin plate structure, plate-type inserts are bulky with many rebar anchors and cannot adapt to thin-plate structures. Channel-type inserts are compact with a single row of rebar anchors, making them the only feasible option. |
| Q4 | What insert products does Daring offer? Daring offers both channel-type inserts (welded and riveted processes) and plate-slot cast-in channels (weld-free plate channel, Type A and Type B), with materials covering Q355 steel and 304/316 stainless steel to meet the anchoring needs of different projects. |
| Q5 | What tests have Daring channel-type inserts and plate-slot cast-in channels passed? Daring channel-type inserts have passed tests at the National Building Materials Testing Center, including 2 million cycles of fatigue resistance and fire resistance. Daring plate-slot cast-in channels have passed tests for zinc coating thickness, mechanical properties, yield strength, elongation and more, meeting the needs of various large-scale projects. |
Daring insert products cover channel-type inserts (welded/riveted) and plate-slot cast-in channels (weld-free plate channel, Type A and Type B), with materials covering Q355 steel and 304/316 stainless steel, manufactured strictly in accordance with standards such as GB/T 38525-2020 and JG/T 560-2019. The products have passed testing at the National Building Materials Testing Center, including 2 million cycles of fatigue resistance and fire resistance, and, paired with Daring T-head bolts, enable flexible three-dimensional adjustment. For insert selection recommendations for a specific project, please contact the Daring technical team.
References
Daring official website — Type B plate-slot cast-in channel product page
Daring official website — Welded channel-type insert product page
Daring official website — Riveted channel-type insert product page
GB/T 38525-2020 Channel-Type Pre-Installed Assemblies for Building Curtain Walls
JG/T 560-2019 Channel-Type Cast-in Inserts for Buildings
GB 50017 Standard for Design of Steel Structures
